Shall We Dance?: A Patriotic Politics for CanadaIn Shall We Dance? Charles Blattberg shows that while a just politics based on dialogue is at the core of Canadians' sense of ourselves as a citizenry, our current forms of dialogue are inadequate. For example, neutralist thinkers such as Pierre Trudeau assume that politics must take place on a unified foundation, with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms having a trumping status when it conflicts with values not contained within it. The final word thus goes to those Supreme Court justices responsible for applying the Constitution. Any dialogue here, it is clear, is of that limited sort known as pleading. Pluralist thinkers such as Kenneth McRoberts, however, defend an approach that is in keeping with the longstanding Canadian political tradition of compromise. For them, we need see that even our most basic rights are open to negotiation, a form of dialogue that aims at accommodation. Blattberg argues that both of these approaches have failed and asserts that the preferred form of dialogue in Canadian politics today should be that of conversation. As he shows, only conversation aims for genuine reconciliation of conflict; only it will help us realize the common good that is at the heart of what he calls a patriotic politics; and only such a politics can help us be true to our history, to our present, and, indeed, to our future. |
Contents
A Canadian Home? | 3 |
Three Ways Three Canadas | 10 |
Who We Were | 39 |
Who We Could Be | 81 |
Divide and Listen | 136 |
Notes | 147 |
| 171 | |
| 189 | |
Other editions - View all
Common terms and phrases
aboriginal adversarial affirm American anglophones approach assert British Cairns called Charles Taylor charter citizenry citizens civic community civic nationalist civil society claim compromise conceive conception concern conflict considered constitutional conversation country’s course culture democracy distinct English Canadian English Canadian nation ensure ethnic example expressive rules federal feel form of dialogue French Canadians fundamental genuine given groups hence hockey Ibid integrated interpreted invoke Isaiah Berlin justice kind language least Lucien Bouchard means Meech Meech Lake Accord ment monarch monarchist negotiation neutralist never non-aboriginals one’s Parliament patriotic pluralist polyarchist polyarchy practice province Québé Quebec Quebec City Québécois Québécois nationalists question reason recognition recognize reconcile referred reform regulations republican requires responsible government rest of Canada seen sense share significant sovereignist sovereignty sovereignty association suggest Taylor tend theory theory of justice there’s thing tion Tragically Hip transformation Trudeau ultimately unity what’s