The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare, Volume 1
Philip Sabin, Hans van Wees, Michael Whitby
Cambridge University Press, Dec 6, 2007 - History - 694 pages
Warfare was the single biggest preoccupation of historians in antiquity. In recent decades fresh textual interpretations, numerous new archaeological discoveries and a much broader analytical focus emphasising social, economic, political and cultural approaches have transformed our understanding of ancient warfare. Volume I of this two-volume History reflects these developments and provides a systematic account, written by a distinguished cast of contributors, of the various themes underlying the warfare of the Greek world from the Archaic to the Hellenistic period and of Early and Middle Republican Rome. For each broad period developments in troop-types, equipment, strategy and tactics are discussed. These are placed in the broader context of developments in international relations and the relationship of warfare to both the state and wider society. Numerous illustrations, a glossary and chronology, and information about the authors mentioned supplement the text. This will become the primary reference work for specialists and non-specialists alike.
What people are saying - Write a review
LibraryThing ReviewUser Review - LibraryThing
In order to cash in on this widely overpriced work, Cambridge University Press dropped all quality standards: Sloppy editing (one contributor repeatedly refers to his non-existent subtitle), sloppy fact-checking (Victor Davis Hanson being Victor Davis Hanson), outdated and language restricted sources, a flawed overall research design and a general non communication among the contributors. In the end, it's a collection of essays of mixed quality, some truly awful, some quite enlightening. The most critical aspect is the flawed research design that breaks down Greek warfare into two periods (classical and Hellenistic) which forces the topic into a bed of Prokrustes. The second flaw of the research design is the presentation of the Greek (and later Roman) side only, a kabuki approach that ignores modern research paradigms and is not helpful in understanding the dynamic element of warfare. Greek warfare did not evolve in a vacuum. Why the editors let Victor Davis Hanson write about "The modern historiography of ancient warfare" is a mystery to me. Azar Gat has written two books about the topics covered and would certainly have written a better essay. Instead, the space is given to Hanson's badly structured, sloppily researched and biased essay. Hanson whose command of the German language (if he reads German at all) and the literature is not proportional to his wide-ranging statements he makes about the German historical school. Hanson being Hanson, he strays from his topic to modern times, only to blunder about "the (20th century) demilitarization oft he Danube" (the last time the Danube was militarized was during the Habsburg Ottoman wars) and "post-Marxist discussion of ancient warfare" (whatever this means, no sources supplied, which seems to be the general approach Hanson takes to opposing views). Overall, a very disappointing result. Cambridge University Press should hang their collective heads in shame.
Hannibal's War: A Military History of the Second Punic War
John Francis Lazenby
Limited preview - 1998
THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF GREEK AND ROMAN WARFARE
978-0-521-78274-6 - The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare, Volume II:. Rome from the Late Republic to the Late Empire. Edited by Philip Sabin, ...
assets.cambridge.org/ 97805217/ 82746/ frontmatter/ 9780521782746_frontmatter.pdf
Prof. Michael Whitby
The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare, joint editor (Cambridge University Press 2007) pp.1271. 'Army and society in the Late Roman World: a ...
www2.warwick.ac.uk/ fac/ arts/ classics/ staff/ michaelwhitby/
UCD Research: School of Classics
The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare, Volume I: Greece, the Hellenistic World and the Rise of Rome. Cambridge: Cambridge universitypress. ...
www.ucd.ie/ research/ publications/ 20062007/ artscelticstudies/ schoolofclassics/
Rez. AG: Ph. Sabin ua (Hrsg.): The Cambridge History of Greek and ...
Titel: The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare. Bd. 1: Greece, the Hellenistic World, and the Rise of Rome; Bd. 2: Rome from the Late Republic to ...
hsozkult.geschichte.hu-berlin.de/ rezensionen/ type=rezbuecher&
Peter Hunt Associate Professor Department of Classics University ...
"Military Forces," in The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare (ed. Philip. Sabin, Hans Van Wees, and Michael Whitby), Cambridge University Press, ...
www.colorado.edu/ Classics/ faculty/ cv/ hunt07.pdf
Swansea University - humphries_mark
... including the Cambridge Ancient History, the Cambridge Dictionary of Classical Civilization, and the Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare. ...
www.swan.ac.uk/ staff/ academic/ Humanities/ humphriesmark/
Titulo: The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare. Autores: Victor Davis Hanson, Simon Hornblower, Michael Whitby, Jonathan Hall, Peter Hunt, ...
Projekt Dyabola blog
Sabin, P.; Wees, H. van; Whitby, M. The Cambridge history of Greek and Roman warfare, 2. Rome from the Republic to the late Empire. ...