Second Witness: Analytical and Contextual Commentary on the Book of Mormon, Volume 5
"This work, the fifth of a six-volume commentary, presents a startling reinterpretation of Mormon's Gadianton robbers. Mormon, working from a cyclical view of history, applied the same name to groups widely separated by time. In a brilliant matching of setting and text, Gardner reconstructs Mormon's conceptual linking of the Gadiantons in 50 B.C. with the warriors from Teotihuacan, the most fearsome war machine in ancient Central Mexico, who crushed the Nephites at Cumorah four centuries later. This volume also covers the hemisphere's most significant religious event: the resurrected Christ's appearance at Bountiful. Gardner reads the Sermon at the Temple against Matthew's Sermon on the Mount, reconstructing important insights about the cultural milieu of both and Joseph Smith's translation process. Gardner also dismantles the long-held belief that the Aztec god Quetzalcoatl is a folk remembrance of Christ. A close examination of Spanish and pre-Spanish native texts results in his conclusion that LDS hopes of seeing the risen Christ in the image of the feathered serpent reflect the same wishful thinking as the early Spanish fathers and end up in the same unconvincing mismatch of apparently Christian traits imposed on recalcitrant native elements."--Bk. jkt.
What people are saying - Write a review
Review: Second Witness: Analytical and Contextual Commentary on the Book of MormonUser Review - Kevin Christensen - Goodreads
To enhance our Sunday School reading of the Book of Mormon, I'm going through Brant's six volume commentary. I'm pleased to see that he makes powerful use of Margaret Barker's work, supplimenting her ... Read full review
Review: Second Witness: Analytical and Contextual Commentary on the Book of MormonUser Review - Kent - Goodreads
Solid. I wish there were more information on each verse, and perhaps less speculation. Still, this is extremely useful, a huge step forward in Mormon commentaries -- just not to the level of non-Mormon biblical commentaries. Read full review