...since the New Rules ; and for the purpose of classifying these cases, I propose to consider,—First, When de injuria may clearly be replied. Secondly,...altogether doubtful whether it can or cannot be replied. In the course of this discussion, I shall have to point out and explain what amounts to mere matter...

...elaborated since the New Rules ; and for the purpose of classifying these cases, I propose to consider,— First, When de injuria may clearly be replied. Secondly,...altogether doubtful whether it can or cannot be replied. In the course of this discussion, I shall have to point out and explain what amounts to mere matter...

...or rather that half of him which was devoted to the technical side of process and pleading," gives a classified exposition of the doctrine, considering...Fourthly, when it is probable it cannot be replied. Fifthly, when it is altogether doubtful whether it can or cannot be replied." The essence of the new...

...is of exaggeration in the satirical gloss which divides the cases of this replication into those : "First, when de injuria may clearly be replied. Secondly,...altogether doubtful whether it can or cannot be replied." 5 A mingling of logic and illogic, not untinctured by tricklings of medieval scholasticism, appears...