Judicial Dictatorship (Google eBook)
American society has undergone a revolution within a revolution. Until the 1960s, America was a liberal country in the traditional sense of legislative and executive checks and balances. Since then, the Supreme Court has taken on the role of the protector of individual rights against the will of the majority by creating, in a series of decisions, new rights for criminal defendants, atheists, homosexuals, illegal aliens, and others. Repeatedly, on a variety of cases, the Court has overturned the actions of local police or state laws under which local officials are acting. The result, according to Quirk and Birdwell, is freedom for the lawless and oppression for the law abiding. Judicial Dictatorship challenges the status quo, arguing that in many respects the Supreme Court has assumed authority far beyond the original intent of the Founding Fathers.
In order to avoid abuse of power, the three branches of the American government were designed to operate under a system of checks and balances. However, this balance has been upset. The Supreme Court has become the ultimate arbiter in the legal system through exercise of the doctrine of judicial review, which allows the court to invalidate any state or federal law it considers inconsistent with the constitution. Supporters of judicial review believe that there has to be a final arbiter of constitutional interpretation, and the Judiciary is the most suitable choice. Opponents, Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln among them, believed that judicial review assumes the judicial branch is above the other branches, a result the Constitution did not intend. The democratic paradox is that the majority in America agreed to limit its own power.
Jefferson believed that the will of the majority must always prevail. His faith in the common man led him to advocate a weak national government, one that derived its power from the people. Alexander Hamilton, often Jefferson's adversary, lacking such faith, feared “the amazing violence and turbulence of the democratic spirit.” This led him to believe in a strong national government, a social and economic aristocracy, and finally, judicial review. This conflict has yet to be resolved. Judicial Dictatorship discusses the issue of who will decide if government has gone beyond its proper powers. That issue, in turn, depends on whether the Jeffersonian or Hamiltonian view of the nature of the person prevails. In challenging customary ideological alignments of conservative and liberal doctrine, Judicial Dictatorship will be of interest to students and professionals in law, political scientists, and those interested in U.S. history.
What people are saying - Write a review
Quirk and Bridwell, Judicial Dictatorship - Mises Economics Blog
Law professor and Mises Adjunct Scholar William J. Quirk's 1995 book, Judicial Dictatorship (with R. Randall Bridwell) is now online (with permission) (How ...
blog.mises.org/ archives/ 003832.asp
operating judicial dictatorship. The United States le- ... JUDICIAL DICTATORSHIP / 35. The majority today only has the most limited kind. of power. ...
www.springerlink.com/ index/ V1031GK36456835Q.pdf
Judicial Dictatorship (Ppr) - Boek - BESLIST.nl
Bekijk en vergelijk informatie, beoordelingen, vragen & antwoorden en de beste winkels voor 'Judicial Dictatorship (Ppr)' op BESLIST.nl ▪ Boeken Engels ...
boeken_engels.beslist.nl/ boeken_engels/ d0000168027/ Judicial_Dictatorship_(Ppr).html
American Renaissance September 1995
Judicial Dictatorship. William J. Quirk & R. Randall Bridwell ... Judicial Dictatorship explains why, and does it so thoroughly it will shame even confirmed ...
www.amren.com/ ar/ 1995/ 09/
Judicial Dictatorship « “OVER HIMSELF, OVER HIS OWN BODY & MIND ...
In a judicial dictatorship, you get a government and society designed by the Supreme Court to conform to its intellectual vision of America. ...
thailibertarian.wordpress.com/ 2007/ 07/ 01/ judicial-dictatorship/
Livros online: marka.pt
Título : Judicial Dictatorship. Tipo : Livro. Autor : Quirk, William J.; Bridwell, Randall. Editor : Transaction Publishers. Ano : 01/1997. Páginas : 158 ...
www.marka.pt/ (S(af1m4fmyiq0wlk45qrgnm055))/ Produto.Aspx?Artigo=00888064
Quirk libri - I Libri dell'autore: Quirk - webster.it
84. Judicial Dictatorship · Judicial Dictatorship di Quirk, R. Bridwell - Transaction Publishers - January 1995. Prezzo: € 29.43 ...
:: esmas compras
Judicial Dictatorship (Judicial Dictatorship Libros Ingles Political Science General Transaction Publishers) N/A Transaction Publishers ...
www.clubcompras.com.mx/ catalogo/ dsp_autor.cfm?autID=358497