There is No Such Thing as a Social Science: In Defence of Peter Winch (Google eBook)
The death of Peter Winch in 1997 sparked a revived interest in his work with this book arguing his work suffered misrepresentation in both recent literature and in contemporary critiques of his writing. Debates in philosophy and sociology about foundational questions of social ontology and methodology often claim to have adequately incorporated and moved beyond Winch's concerns. Re-establishing a Winchian voice, the authors examine how such contentions involve a failure to understand central themes in Winch's writings and that the issues which occupied him in his Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy and later papers remain central to social studies. The volume offers a careful reading of the text in alliance with Wittgensteinian insights and alongside a focus on the nature and results of social thought and inquiry. It draws parallels with other movements in the social studies, notably ethnomethodology, to demonstrate how Winch's central claim is both more significant and more difficult to transcend than sociologists and philosophers have hitherto imagined.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Beyond Pluralism Monism Relativism Realism etc
Winch and Linguistic Idealism
activity actually argument attempt Azande beliefs causal chapter claim communities concepts confusion conservatism context Conversation Analysis criteria criticise criticism critique culture deﬁnite difﬁculties discussion doctrines empirical engaged ethnomethodology Evans-Pritchard evolutionary psychologist example explanation extensional fact ﬁlm ﬁnd ﬁnding ﬁrst Garﬁnkel genuine God Delusion Goffman grasp Habermas idea identiﬁed inﬂuence inquiry internal relations interpretation involved kind Kuhn language language-game linguistic matter Mauritius meaning metaphysical method methodology misunderstanding notion oneís ontological reductionism Peter Winch philosophy of social Pollnerís possibility practices problems question quietism rational reality recognise reductionism reﬂection relativism representation rule-following rules Schatzki scientiﬁc sense signiﬁcance simply social action social science social scientists social studies social theory society sociological theory sociologists sociology someone speciﬁc Steinerís substantive talk theoretical things thought truth truth-claim trying Understanding a Primitive washing witchcraft Wittgenstein and Winch Wittgensteinís philosophy Wittgensteinian words writings