Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said's Orientalism

Front Cover
Prometheus Books, 2007 - Literary Criticism - 556 pages
3 Reviews
This is the first systematic critique of Edward Said's influential work, Orientalism, a book that for almost three decades has received wide acclaim, voluminous commentary, and translation into more than fifteen languages. Saidís main thesis was that the Western image of the East was heavily biased by colonialist attitudes, racism, and more than two centuries of political exploitation. Although Saidís critique was controversial, the impact of his ideas has been a pervasive rethinking of Western perceptions of Eastern cultures, plus a tendency to view all scholarship in Oriental Studies as tainted by considerations of power and prejudice.

In this thorough reconsideration of Saidís famous work, Ibn Warraq argues that Saidís case against the West is seriously flawed. Warraq accuses Said of not only willfully misinterpreting the work of many scholars, but also of systematically misrepresenting Western civilization as a whole. With example after example, he shows that ever since the Greeks Western civilization has always had a strand in its very makeup that has accepted non-Westerners with open arms and has ever been open to foreign ideas.

The author also criticizes Said for inadequate methodology, incoherent arguments, and a faulty historical understanding. He points out, not only Saidís tendentious interpretations, but historical howlers that would make a sophomore blush.

Warraq further looks at the destructive influence of Said's study on the history of Western painting, especially of the 19th century, and shows how, once again, the epigones of Said have succeeded in relegating thousands of first-class paintings to the lofts and storage rooms of major museums.

An extended appendix reconsiders the value of 18th- and 19th-century Orientalist scholars and artists, whose work fell into disrepute as a result of Saidís work.

From inside the book

What people are saying - Write a review

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - quantum_flapdoodle - LibraryThing

A Muslim apostate takes on Said's Orientalism, standing up for the values of western civilization that he feels have allowed him (and Said) to have the freedom to speak their mind. He suggests that ... Read full review

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - juglicerr - LibraryThing

Ibn Warraq has created a powerful critique of Said's Orientalism, approaching the subject from several angles. He begins the book with a slightly rewritten essay that contains the essentials of his ... Read full review

Contents

Edward Said and the Saidists
18
The Three Golden Threads and the Misapprehensions of Edward Said
55
Three Tutelary Guiding Lights
57
Copyright

24 other sections not shown

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2007)

Ibn Warraq is the highly acclaimed author of Why I Am Not a Muslim and Defending the West. He is also the editor of The Origins of the Koran, What the Koran Really Says, Leaving Islam, The Quest for the Historical Muhammad, and Which Koran?.

Bibliographic information