Not in Our Classrooms: Why Intelligent Design is Wrong for Our Schools
Eugenie Carol Scott, Glenn Branch
Beacon Press, 2006 - Education - 171 pages
More than eighty years after the Scopes trial, creationism is alive and well. Through local school boards, sympathetic politicians, and well-funded organizations, a strong movement has developed to encourage the teaching of the latest incarnation of creationism—intelligent design—as a scientifically credible theory alongside evolution in science classes. Although intelligent design suffered a serious defeat in the recent Kitzmiller v. Dover trial, its proponents are bound to continue their assault on evolution education. Now, in Not in Our Classrooms, parents and teachers, as well as other concerned citizens, have a much-needed tool to use in the argument against teaching intelligent design as science.
Where did the concept of intelligent design originate? How does it connect with, and conflict with, various religious beliefs? Should we teach the controversy itself in our science classrooms? In clear and lively essays, a team of experts answers these questions and many more, describing the history of the intelligent design movement and the lack of scientific support for its claims. Most importantly, the contributors—authorities on the scientific, legal, educational, and theological problems of intelligent design—speak specifically to teachers and parents about the need to defend the integrity of science education by keeping intelligent design out of science curriculums. A concluding chapter offers concrete advice for those seeking to defend the teaching of evolution in their own communities.
Not in Our Classrooms is essential reading for anyone concerned about defending the teaching of evolution, uncompromised by religiously motivated pseudoscience, in the classrooms of our public schools.
"The book you have in your hands is an excellent resource to deal with the attack on evolution, which is a surrogate, and indeed a wedge, for a wide-ranging crusade against the scientific integrity of the public education system in America."
—Rev. Barry W. Lynn, from the Foreword
"The future of our species probably depends on science education and our understanding of the natural world. If you're concerned about science literacy, read this book."
—Bill Nye the Science Guy®
"…we are in the midst of a struggle to preserve sound science education…It is crucial to resist such pressure, whether it comes from parents, community groups, administrators, or school board members. Reading this book is a good start." —Howard Good, Teacher Magazine
"Not in Our Classrooms makes its case well, underscoring the fatuousness of creationist science on every level: constitutional, educational and scientific…At its core, the evolution "debate" is a local one, and it's at that level that the daily battles happen. Thanks to this collection, winning them might become a little easier."
—Washington Monthly, review in the January/February issue
"In Not in Our Classrooms Beacon Press has provided the indispensable tool for combating this grave threat to science and science education . . . This important book cannot be recommended too highly."
—Voice of Reason: The Journal of Americans for Religious Liberty, review in the No. 4 2006 issue
"This book provides substantial background information and perspective…such information and analysis can only help social justice educators."
—Rethinking Schools, review in the Winter issue
"It is a welcome and recommended addition to a library of materials that strengthen and enlighten science instruction in the era of a narrowly defined theism in the United States today . . . recommended for teachers, citizens, and policymakers."
—National Science Teachers Association
"For teachers, school boards, and citizens who are interested in learning about intelligent design (ID) creationism and counteracting it, this book is a vital resource." —Teachers College Record
Eugenie C. Scott and Glenn Branch are the executive director and the deputy director of the National Center for Science Education, a nonprofit organization in Oakland, California, that defends the teaching of evolution in the public schools. Scott's Evolution vs. Creationism: An Introduction was named an Outstanding Academic Title of 2005 by Choice.
Since 1992 the Reverend Barry W. Lynn, a minister in the United Church of Christ, has served as executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State.
What people are saying - Write a review
LibraryThing ReviewUser Review - quantum_flapdoodle - LibraryThing
A book of contributed papers on the topic of intelligent design and why we shouldn't be teaching it in our classrooms. With the exception of one paper, which seemed to be more sympathetic with ID than ... Read full review
LibraryThing ReviewUser Review - fyrefly98 - LibraryThing
Summary: Although the Scopes trial was almost 90 years ago, the issue of evolution education in American schools is still a contentious issue. Although strict creationism has been for the most part ... Read full review
The Once and Future Intelligent Design
Analyzing Critical Analysis The Fallback Antievolutionist Strategy
Theology Religion and Intelligent Design
From the Classroom to the Courtroom Intelligent Design and the Constitution
Evolution in the Classroom
Defending the Teaching of Evolution Strategies and Tactics for Activists