The 'Language Instinct' Debate: Revised Edition
When it was first published in 1997, Geoffrey Sampson's Educating Eve was described as the definitive response to Steven Pinker's The Language Instinct and Noam Chomsky's nativism. In this revised and expanded new edition, Sampson revisits his original arguments in the light of fresh evidence that has emerged since the original publication.
Since Chomsky revolutionized the study of language in the 1960s, it has increasingly come to be accepted that language and other knowledge structures are hard-wired in our genes. According to this view, human beings are born with a rich structure of cognition already in place. But people do not realize how thin the evidence for that idea is.
The 'Language Instinct' Debate examines the various arguments for instinctive knowledge, and finds that each one rests on false premisses or embodies logical fallacies. The structures of language are shown to be purely cultural creations.
With a new chapter entitled 'How People Really Speak' which uses corpus data to analyse how language is used in spontaneous English conversation, responses to critics, extensive revisions throughout, and a new preface by Paul Postal of New York University, this new edition will be an essential purchase for students, academics, and general readers interested in the debate about the 'language instinct'.
What people are saying - Write a review
As a scientific adviser to graduate students and as a PhD in linguistics I have to say that I struggle with Sampson's book for several reasons. First I have a problem with his use of hyperbole such as "most people" (p. 7), "very many people" (p. 1), "some people" (p. 11), "no one would read Chomsky..." (p. 13) and "All academic philosophers know" (p. 19). These are just a few examples I found in Chapter One. His book is filled with this type of assumptive speech once called "Dicto Simpliciter." He also seems to struggle with Hasty Generalizations. I fear that Sampson has failed to keep up with the data concerning new research in language and speech production. Technology has given us tools beyond imagination and as a result we have new insights into language production, language development and how humans speak. Dr. Deb Roy from MIT (cognitive scientist) has done extensive research on the emergence of language in infants. Dr. Faraneh Vargha-Khadem from University College London has actually isolated the Fox P2 gene responsible for certain types of speech defects and Prof. Gary Morgan's studies into autism shows that some brains have no language barrier at all and can master all the skills of 20 languages. I just have to say that I cannot recommend a book with these types of over generalizations. In addition, it seems that Sampson is angry or acidic towards nativists in general, Chomsky and Pinker in particular. He almost rants in the first three chapters. The evidence of a language instinct is no longer thin, but rather exploding as technology allows us to look into what makes us speak. All of this to say that language cannot be purely cultural if genetic mutations can deform it.
Review: The 'Language Instinct' DebateUser Review - Katja - Goodreads
The book tries to make a very important point: there is not enough evidence to believe in the innateness of the language faculty, despite many linguists claiming the opposite. The preface makes it ... Read full review
Other editions - View all
Blackwell Synergy - Modern Language J, Volume 91 Issue 3 Page 486 ...
The ‘Language Instinct’ Debate by SAMPSON, GEOFFREY. JULIA HERSCHENSOHN11University of Washington. 1University of Washington. SAMPSON, GEOFFREY. ...
www.blackwell-synergy.com/ doi/ abs/ 10.1111/ j.1540-4781.2007.00593_14.x
JSTOR: Educating Eve: The 'Language Instinct' Debate
BOOK REVIEWS Educating Eve: The 'language instinct' debate. By GEOFFREY SAMPSON. (Open linguis- tics series.) London & New York: Cassell, 1997. Pp. 184. ...
Geoffrey Sampson: The "Language Instinct" Debate
The ‘Language Instinct’ Debate is a critique of this idea. It is an enlarged and revised edition of a book first published in Britain under the title ...
Sampson -- Educating Eve: The Language Instinct Debate -- 1999
Sampson, G. Educating Eve: The Language Instinct Debate (Cassell Academic, London, 1999). 1999, -, Syntax as an emergent characteristic of the evolution of ...
www.isrl.uiuc.edu/ ~amag/ langev/ cited2/ sampsonedugevethelanguageinctdebate.html
ingentaconnect The Language Instinct Debate by SAMPSON, GEOFFREY
The `Language Instinct' Debate by SAMPSON, GEOFFREY. Author: HERSCHENSOHN, JULIA1. Source: The Modern Language Journal, Volume 91, Number 3, Fall 2007 , pp. ...
www.ingentaconnect.com/ content/ bpl/ modl/ 2007/ 00000091/ 00000003/ art00023;jsessionid=7h35dart47f1q.alexandra?format=pr...
The 'language instinct' debate, rev. ed | Reference & Research ...
The language instinct debate, rev. ed from Reference & Research Book News in Reference provided free by Find Articles.
findarticles.com/ p/ articles/ mi_m0QLQ/ is_3_20/ ai_n15394761
Linguist List - Book Information
Title: The 'Language Instinct' Debate. E-mail this message to a friend ... The 'Language Instinct' Debate examines the various arguments for instinctive ...
www.linguistlist.org/ pubs/ books/ get-book.cfm?BookID=15339
Waterstones.com: Reference and Languages: The Language Instinct ...
The Language Instinct Debate Close Window.
www.waterstones.com/ waterstonesweb/ displayProductDetailsZoom.do?sku=4345200
認知言語学的メモ : The ‘Language Instinct’ Debate
Geoffrey Sampson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 Publications authored. Sampson, G: The 'Language Instinct' Debate (Continuum, 2004, ISBN 0-8264-7385).  References ...
en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/ Geoffrey_Sampson