The Necessity of Inspiration and the Crisis of Modern Political Communication
ProQuest, 2008 - 273 pages
My dissertation seeks to fully recover one of the most important elements of republicanism---and yet an element of republicanism that is overlooked in most of the literature---persuasive political rhetoric ("rhetoric-as- movere") in order to improve political communication and participation in the United States. Through rhetoric-as-movere is not without its problems, I argue that it has two major advantages over the type of political communication necessitated by strict deliberative democracy, a type of political communication that I suggest is rooted in "rhetoric-as-docere," a tradition that developed alongside the rise of scientific empiricism in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries: it is better at drawing out action from novice citizens because it does a better job than deliberative democracy of dealing with the barriers to political entry, and it is more inclusive. Rhetoric-as-movere allows an orator to explicitly make use of all the persuasive tools at his or her disposal. While it is true that these tools are at times contrary to "rationality," throughout history they have always been the first recourse of leaders and movements truly concerned with popular participation. I demonstrate this affinity between rhetoric-as- movere and popular participation through an historical survey of movements ranging from 14th century English peasant revolts to 20th century American civil rights movements. I also analyze the development of the rhetoric-as-docere tradition in thinkers like Hobbes, Smith and Hume. I conclude that the rhetoric-as-docere tradition, which includes contemporary deliberative democracy, is predicated upon a suspicion of popular action that renders it insufficient as a model of political communication.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
The Necessity of Inspiration
Lessons from Medieval History
The Emerging Alternative
Hobbes Against Movere
The Legacy of Politeness in the EnglishSpeaking Tradition
Doceres American Ascent and the Counterexample of Marx
Preliminary Steps for Addressing the Crisis of Political
able American appeals argue argument Aristotle attack audience Bacon believe Cambridge chapter Cicero citizens civic classical republicanism classical rhetoric conception concerned contemporary copia create critical curriculum deliberation deliberative democracy demagogues democratic demonstrate discourse discussion docere eighteenth century empirical England English Civil War Essay ethos example Francis Bacon functions of rhetoric-as-movere glory goal Hobbes Hobbes's Hume Ibid idea important improper demagogic individualist republicanism inspire institutions intellectual King language liberalism liberty literature Marx model of political modern movement movere norms orator pamphlets participatory democracy passion period persuasion Petrus Ramus Philosophy Piers Plowman Plato polite plain speech political communication political elites political instability political participation political theory popular government popular political action Populist praedicandi problem of homogeneity proofs Quentin Skinner Quintilian Ramus Renaissance restraining function rhetoric-as rhetorical education Royal Society scholars seventeenth century Shaftesbury Smith Sprat Tale of Melibee Thomas Hobbes tradition treatises urging and restraining writes