User Review - Flag as inappropriate
The first half of the book covers the early history of probability and statistics, which was fascinating as it overlapped a lot with "A short history of nearly everything."
Too often the author tries to make a concept more concrete by using stock market examples, but short term movements of stock themselves aren't concretely understood.
Towards the end, the author just touches on the concepts of behavioral economics and derivatives, which made me really want to learn more. Fortunately, I know what books to read next.
User Review - Flag as inappropriate
Academic and ‘the best writer in the world of finance’
Economist and author 1919-2009
Nobody did more than Peter Bernstein, who died last week at the age of 90, to bring together the worlds of high finance and academic research.
After a career as an academic economist and successful investor, he spent the long years of what might have been his retirement writing a series of best-selling books that revolutionised common understanding of investment – notably Against the Gods,a history of risk management, and Capital Ideas,onthe notions of market efficiency that underpinned the growth of modern finance.
In doing so, he retained the respect of people on all sides of the impassioned debate over the validity of theories based on the assumption that markets are rational. Last year’s financial implosion has prompted sharper criticism of his “capital ideas” and Bernstein kept contributing to the debate – last week, with a speech delivered posthumously to a conference in Canada.
Robert Arnott, former editor of the Financial Analysts Journal, and an often abrasive critic of these theories, was also a friend of Bernstein for 30 years, and read out the speech. He described Bernstein as “the best writer in the world of finance”.
“While he respected the power of quantitative models and methods, and loved the elegance of modern finance theory enough to write Capital Ideas, he also recognised that theory is theory,” said Mr Arnott. “It’s an approximation of the real world; it’s not reality. He relished poking holes in our industry’s over-reliance on theory and historically rooted models.”
Arguably, it was the over-reliance on theoretical abstractions that led to disaster last year, not the theories themselves. And Bernstein warned in Against the Gods, written a decade before the crisis broke: “Our faith in risk management encourages us to take risks that we would not otherwise take...How can we program into the computer concepts that we cannot program into ourselves, that are even beyond our imagination?”
Unlike the academics who built his “capital ideas,” Bernstein had very tangible experience of dealing with risk in the real world. Born in New York in 1919, the son of a Wall Streeter, he lived through the years of the Great Crash. After graduating from Harvard, where he studied economics under Joseph Schumpeter, he joined the Organisation of Strategic Services, precursor of the Central Intelligence Agency. He was stationed in London during Hitler’s campaign of rocket attacks.
After a stint as an academic, at Williams College in Massachusetts, he came to grips with financial risk as a loan officer for a bank, and then spent many years running the family investment management firm, where he had to work out price/earnings ratios with a slide rule.
He sold it (to Citigroup founder Sandy Weill) and built his own investment advisory group. He also launched the Journal of Portfolio Management, which became the central forum for applying academic theories to finance.
Although he is best known as an apostle of “capital ideas”, he had equal enthusiasm for the attempts to dispute the theories, often using research from behavioural psychology.
His last major book, Capital Ideas Evolving, published two years ago when he was 88, led off with a lengthy section on the behaviouralists bent on picking holes in the efficient markets theory, including Richard Thaler, Robert Shiller and Andrew Lo, whose “adaptive markets hypothesis”, which applies biology to markets, is a well-known alternative to efficient markets.
“Over the years, I’ve received many notes from Peter, usually typed, always signed, and each one made an insightful point about either my research or his, and I’ve benefited tremendously from his wisdom,” Mr Lo said.
For Mr Lo, Bernstein “single-handedly raised the level of discourse in the investments industry” by creating a forum where theories were “confronted with the realities of
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Cameron - Goodreads
This is an excellent book from the dawn of pop-science for risk management / decision making. It is a history of the development of mathematical tools, societal changes and financial mechanisms to ... Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Jennifer - Goodreads
Whether you understand probability or not, read this book. It's exciting math history. Seriously. There's gambling too. Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Charlie Brummitt - Goodreads
The early history of risk, such as people at Lloyd's coffeeshop in London underwriting trips to the New World, was interesting. The second half of the book was more familiar to me, and it was not the best treatment of these topics in probability, chaos, mathematical finance. Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Ajt568 - Goodreads
I was hoping for a history of statistics but this was heavily bent to financial risk especially the second part. Should have read the title. I found it a good read and not poor as some comments have suggested. Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Regiment95 - Goodreads
Some parts a bit too technical, but a fascinating read. Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Boris Mikhailovski - Goodreads
historical account of risks Read full review
Review: Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of RiskUser Review - Snow Queen - Goodreads
Interesting subject and useful information. However Bernstein's wordings is rather obscure and some paragraph are completely repeating and redundant. Anyway, I still liked the content of the book Read full review