A True European: Essays for Judge David Edward

Front Cover
David A. O. Edward, Mark Hoskins, William Robinson
Hart Publishing, 2003 - Law - 399 pages
0 Reviews
Judge David Edward has enjoyed a spectacular career. After a substantial, successful period in Scotland, both as a practicing advocate and professor of EC law, he was appointed to the Court of First Instance upon its creation in 1989. He was subsequently appointed to the Court of Justice where he has served for many years. This book has been prepared in honor of his retirement from that position in December 2003. The contributions reflect all aspects of Judge Edward's career as a lawyer, both in Scotland and in Luxembourg. In keeping with the respect with which he is held, contributions have been received from eminent members of the Scottish and Luxembourg judiciary, academics and practitioners. Not surprisingly, the main focus is on community law, with important contributions on competition, institutional, substantive and remedial issues. This book will be an essential addition to the library of anyone with a genuine interest in community law.
 

What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.

Contents

Tales from the Tartan Chambers
1
What Waldemar SawA Young Germans View of
11
Secretary of State ex parte Trade Union Congress 2000 IRLR 565 CA 320
19
Justice Seen to be Done
21
Fratelli Grassi Case 572 1972 ECR 443 348
24
Unfinished Business
31
Case C26302P Commission v JégoQuéré et Cie SA pending 339
40
Worcester Works Finance Ltd 1968 3 All ER 104 263
44
Guimont Case C44898 2000 ECR I10663 337
250
Conseil national de lordre des architectes v Dreessen Case C3100
251
Cooke Case C18597 1998 ECR I5199 311 371
257
Strathclyde Regional Council 1986 SLT 530 38
258
Case C10898 RI SAN Srl v Comune di Ischia Italia Lavro SpA
262
Ingmar GB Ltd v Eaton Leonard Technologies Inc Case C38198
265
Standard of Review in WTO Law
267
Jackson and Others v Owusu Case C28102 pending 261
293

Comet Case 4576 1976 ECR 2043 317
45
Devolution and Community Law
47
Midlothian District Council 1983 HL 50
50
Belgium Case 14979 1982 ECR 1845
54
Case 8378 Redmond 1978 ECR 2347
57
Joined Cases T13296 and T14396 Freistaat Sachsen Volkswagen AG
62
The Convention and the Court
69
JégoQuéré et Cie SA Case C26302P pending 339
73
The Judicial Architecture of the European Unionthe Challenges
81
Guardian Royal Exchange Assurance Group Case C26288
88
Judge Edward Acting as Advocate General
91
Case 12578 GEMA v Commission 1979 ECR 3173
94
Béguelin Import v G L Import Export Case 2271 1971 ECR 949 166
98
Enlargement of the European Unionthe Council Process
99
Certain Reflections on Recent Judgments Reviewing Commission
117
Case T1399 Pfizer Animal Health v Commission 2002 ECR II3305 204 205
118
Sytraval et Brinks France SARL Case C36795P 1998 ECR I1719
119
GIE Groupe Concorde and Others v Master of the vessel Suhadiwarno Panjan
124
Compassion In World Farming Case C196 1998 ECR I1251 57
125
Case C1303P Commission v Tetra Laval pending
137
The National Courts and the Uniform Application of EC Competition
145
Case 14979 Commission v Belgium 1982 ECR 1845 54
153
UNITED KINGDOM CASES
155
Hauptzollamt Frankfurt am MainOst Case C13095 1997 ECR I4291 333 Government of Gibraltar v Council Case C 29889 1993 ECR I3605 63
157
Collective DominanceThe Contribution of the Community Courts
161
Case C11194 Job Centre Coop Sarl 1995 ECR I3361 335
164
Bickel and Franz Case C27496 1998 ECR I7637 244
167
Cases listed in alphabetical order
171
Some Reflections on Procedure in Competition Cases
187
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES
189
Case C32688 Hansen 1990 ECR I2911 312
195
Akman Case C21097 1998 ECR I7519 243
201
The Dangers of too Much Precaution
203
Case 15779 Pieck 1980 ECR 2171 239
216
Different but Almost EqualThe Development of Free Movement
233
Bosman Case C41593 1995 ECR I4921 168 310 335
237
Novasam Case 24786 1988 ECR 5987 163
241
Case C3798 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department ex parte Savas
242
Brian Francis Collins v Minister of State for Works and Pensions
244
Diplomas and the Recognition of Professional Qualifications in
247
Approaches to Interpretation in a Plurilingual System
297
Mackman 1983 2 AC 237 31
301
Patterson 1980 JC 57
302
Case 2662 1963 ECR 1 54 83 235 307 311 314 327 330 365 385
307
Joined Cases C690 and C990 Francovich and Bonifaci v Italy
309
Case C9192 Faccini Dori v Recreb Srl 1994 ECR I3325 310 314 353 371 376
310
Case C19598 Österreichischer Gewerkschaftsbund Gewerkschaft öffentlicher
311
Hamilton PF Dunfermline v Whitelock Case 7986 1987 ECR 2363 328
312
General Council of Medical Education and Registration
313
Case C1890 Office national de lemploi v Kziber 1991 ECR I199 386
315
Hall 1997 QB 924 44
318
American Cyanamid v Ethicon Ltd 1975 AC396
320
Case C20890 Emmott v Minister for Social Welfare 1991
323
A Few Rough Edges Still
327
Wagner Miret v Fondo de garantia Salarial Case C33492 1993 ECR I6911 371
328
Case 6680 International Chemical Corporation ICI v Amministrazione
329
Case C26090 Leplat v Territory of French Polynesia 1992 ECR I643
332
Case C16794 Grau Gomis and ors 1995 ECR I1023
333
Case C15792 Pretore di Genova v Banchero Banchero I
334
Case C28198 Angonese v Cassa di Risparmio di Bolzano
336
Annibaldi Case C30996 1997 ECR I7493 57
339
Case C16991 Council of the City of StokeonTrent v B Q
340
Secretary of State for the Home Department Case C46600
341
Salò v Persons Unknown Case 1486 1987 ECR 2545
342
To Refer or not to Refer?
345
Joined Cases C43093 and C43193 van Schijndel v SPF 1995 ECR I4705
346
Professional Contractors Group v Commissioners of Inland Revenue
350
Direct Applicability or Effect
353
Case C35195 Kadiman v Fieistaat Bayern 1997 ECR I2133 243
363
Du concept de leffet direct à celui de linvocabilité au regard de
367
Case C32298 Grimaldi v Fonds des maladies professionnelles 1989 ECR 4407
371
Land Berlin Case C28595 1997 ECR I3069 242
376
Chemische Afvalstoffen Dusseldorp Case C20396 1998 ECR I4075 201
380
Commission Case C10497P 1999 ECR I6983
383
Case C43493 Bozkurt v Staatssecretaris van Justitie 1995 ECR I1475 237 271
384
Case 10481 Hauptzollamt Mainz v Kupferberg Cie KgaA
385
Case C37798 Netherlands v Parliament and Council 2001 I7079 73
387
Index
391
United States
398
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2003)

Mark Hoskins is a Barrister and member of Brick Court Chambers,London and Brussels.William Robinson is a Partner of Freshfields, Bruckhaus, Deringer, London.

Bibliographic information