A probabilistic analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti evidence
A Probabilistic Analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti Evidence is a Bayesian analysis of the trial and post-trial evidence in the Sacco and Vanzetti case, based on subjectively determined probabilities and assumed relationships among evidential events. It applies the ideas of charting evidence and probabilistic assessment to this case, which is perhaps the ranking cause celebre in all of American legal history. Modern computation methods applied to inference networks are used to show how the inferential force of evidence in a complicated case can be graded. The authors employ probabilistic assessment to obtain opinions about how influential each group of evidential items is in reaching a conclusion about the defendants' innocence or guilt.
A Probabilistic Analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti Evidence holds particular interest for statisticians and probabilists in academia and legal consulting, as well as for the legal community, historians, and behavioral scientists. It combines structural and probabilistic ideas in the analysis of masses of evidence from every recognized logical species of evidence. Twenty-eight charts show the chains of reasoning in defense of the relevance of evidentiary matters and a listing of trial witnesses who provided the evidence. References include nearly 300 items drawn from the fields of probability theory, history, law, artificial intelligence, psychology, literature, and other areas.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Different Wine in an Old Bottle
A Standpoint for Our Analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti Evidence
Chains of Reasoning from a Mass of Evidence
8 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
analysis anarchists ancillary evidence April 15 arcs arguments arrested Bayes's rule Bayesian believe bullet chains of reasoning concern conditional probability consider constructed credibility dence directly relevant evidence discussed East Braintree epistemic probabilities Equation event evidence charts evidence items evidential Faulkner's testimony favoring Sacco's Figure firearms evidence fired Exhibit 28 fired through Exhibit force of evidence Frantello Gambera given that Sacco Guiderris historians holistic hypotheses identified inference networks inferential innocence involved items of evidence judgments jurors Kadane Kolmogorov axioms likelihood ratio mass of evidence murder car node Parmenter Pelser's testimony penultimate probanda person police post-trial evidence posterior probabilities prior probabilities probabilistic reasoning probability that Sacco probandum probative force prosecution psychophysics reasonable doubt robbery and shooting Sacco and Vanzetti Sacco fired Schum Section shot Berardelli South Braintree crime Starrs story task tell testified tion trial and post-trial trial evidence Vanzetti evidence Wade's testimony Wigmore charts Wigmorean Young and Kaiser