A Skeptical Note on the New EconometricsOne suggestion for coping with the Lucas critique of applied econometric research is to estimate the taste and technology parametersthat presumably underlie supply and demand curves. Proponents of this approach generally interpret economy-wide data on prices and quantities as the results of optimization problems solved by representative consumers and firms. Theoretical first-order conditions (normally linear)for interior solutions are then used to convert observed data intoestimates of the taste and technology parameters of representative agents.This brief paper points to a hazard in this type of research.Specifically, the new style of econometrics can lead to serious error if the economy-wide data are not in fact generated by interior optima of representative agents, but rather come from aggregating over agents that behave quite differently.In an example where the market-wide demand curve is smooth eventhough each individual's demand function is a step function, the procedures of the new econometrics are shown to lead to grievous errors even though all consumers optimize and the econometrician is assumed to know the precise form of the utility function. It is argued that this example is of quite general applicability, and that the simpler procedures of "old fashioned" econometrics may be less hazardous. |
Common terms and phrases
1092 NATIONAL BUREAU ¹See Abraham and James applied econometric applied econometrician Blinder Bureau of Economic buy X2 consumer's Deficits demand function depicted in Figure directly observed discrete choice ECONOMETRICS Alan Economic Research economy-wide data Equilibrium estimate the slopes estimate the taste estimated demand curve example Fullerton The Taxation Hansen and Sargent indifference curve interpret Joseph E King and Don Lars E.0 lead to grievous least squares log(1+X₁ Lucas critique Macroeconomic market demand curve Medoff Length Mishkin Monetary Policy NBER WORKING PAPER Number Author numeraire old econometrics optimization problems solved plim  price and quantity rational expectations Real Interest Rates regime change representative consumer Richard Quandt Robert Sebastian Edwards SERIES A SKEPTICAL SKEPTICAL NOTE solved by representative stochastic process style of econometric suggested supply and demand supply curve taste and technology taste parameter technology parameters Torsten Persson tPt+1 true demand curve utility function Victor Zarnowitz West Germany X₁ X₂t ду