Against Perfectionism: Defending Liberal Neutrality

Front Cover
University of Toronto Press, Jan 19, 2008 - Political Science - 352 pages
0 Reviews

In a democracy, political authority should be determined independently of religious, philosophical, and ethical ideals that often divide us. This idea, called liberal neutrality, challenges one of the oldest insights of the Western philosophical tradition in politics. At least since Plato, the concept of perfectionism has insisted that statecraft is akin to "soulcraft," and political questions about the justification of state power have followed from ethical questions about what is valuable in life and about how we should live if we are to live well.

Against Perfectionism defends neutralist liberalism as the most appropriate political morality for democratic societies. Steven Lecce investigates the theoretical foundations of liberalism, bringing together classic and contemporary arguments about the implications of pluralism for liberal equality. He surveys three classic debates over the grounds and limits of tolerance, and investigates the limits of perfectionism as a guide to law and public policy in pluralist societies. Lecce ultimately suggests a version of neutrality that answers the critiques recently leveled against it as a political ideal. Presenting sophisticated and groundbreaking arguments, Against Perfectionism is a call to rethink current concepts of law and public policy in democratic societies.


What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.


PART ONEThree Classic Controversies
1 Putting Up with Heresy
2 Freedom for Eccentrics
3 Is Prostitution Unpatriotic?
PART TWOLiberalism Today
4 Should Liberals be Perfectionists?
PART THREEDefending Liberal Neutrality
7 Democratic Equality
8 Against the Epistemic Turn
9 Beyond the Basic Structure
10 How Political Is the Personal?

5 The Continuity Thesis
A Critique

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2008)

Steven Lecce is an assistant professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Manitoba.

Bibliographic information