Alcohol Education: What We Must Do
In spite of a massive national investment in alcohol education, the evidence clearly demonstrates that our current efforts are overwhelmingly ineffective and are often counterproductive. The assessment of the effectiveness of alcohol education programs over the past 15 years reveals that those based on the responsible-use approach tend to be superior to those based on the abstinence approach. Hanson puts the historical relationship between Americans and alcohol into perspective, discusses federal policies on alcohol that are highly ideological and biased, and advocates the development of responsible-use curricula that will prepare students to be, as adults, responsible consumers of alcohol. While alcohol has been praised as a sign of refinement, a source of relaxation, and a complement to good times, it has also been cursed as the cause of disease and death. The temperance movement, which taught that alcohol was poison and that moderation in its use was no more possible than moderation in murder, has greatly influenced American thought and is reflected in our abstinence-oriented approach to alcohol education. Current programs reflect not only these abstinence origins but the inclusion of drug education several decades ago. Hanson finds that, despite good intentions, evidence indicates that this approach has proved ineffective. He considers the strong and often mixed feelings Americans have toward alcohol that are reflected in ever-changing public policy and concludes that the development and evaluation of alcohol education programs should be based on the best scientific evidence available rather than on political ideology. Recommendations for change in alcohol education are presented, with the most important being that we must promote the development and evaluation of diverse responsible-use curricula with the goal of reducing alcohol abuse.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Issues in Alcohol Education
The Effectiveness of Alcohol Education
Conclusion and Recommendations
2 other sections not shown
abstinence adolescent alcohol abuse Alcohol and Drug alcohol consumption alcohol education program alcohol knowledge alcohol problems alcoholic beverages American Anti-Saloon League Asbury asserted assessed attitudes and behaviors beer blood alcohol content classroom college students control group control students curricula Department of Education drinkers drinking behavior driving Drug Abuse drug and alcohol drug education program drug prevention effects of alcohol Eighteenth Amendment evaluation experimental and control experimental group experimental students federal follow-up test grade students Health Education Hunt increase in knowledge Journal of Alcohol Journal of Drug knowledge and attitudes liquor marijuana Mary Hunt Mendelson and Mello moderation National no-use programs participated peer poison post-test pre-test prevent alcohol Prevention of Alcohol prevention program prohibition reduction-of-consumption refusal skills reported responsible drinking Scientific Temperance Instruction significant differences significant increase significantly social Substance Abuse teachers teaching temperance movement textbooks University Unpublished M.S. thesis values clarification WCTU wine York