American Crucible: Race and Nation in the Twentieth Century

Front Cover
Princeton University Press, 2001 - History - 454 pages
1 Review

"Historians and social scientists have been longing for ambitious syntheses that take into account recent contributions to social history and studies of culture while reinvigorating key themes in political history. This book's rich and learned assessment of the complexities of twentieth-century America and its appraisal of change provide just such a powerful diagnostic and temporal framework. Showing how civic and racial ideals have entwined to produce both expansive and restrictive results, "American Crucible" is thoughtfully instructive and lovely to read."--Ira Katznelson, Ruggles Professor of Political Science and History, Columbia University.

"Fifty years ago, prominent historians celebrated the virtues of the 'American Creed' thirty years ago, their successors deplored the evils of 'Amerikka.' The best contemporary historians transcend these stereotypes by analyzing the many facets of Americanism, and "American Crucible" now sets the standard for the others. Its demonstration of how civic nationalism and racial nationalism change and how they change each other, its smooth movement from high diplomacy to comic strips, its refusal to settle for easy condemnation or celebration-together they add up to a terrific achievement."--Jennifer Hochschild, Harvard University

"In "American Crucible," Gary Gerstle traces the fundamental tension between the American belief in equality and the deeply rooted tradition of racial nationalism-the most significant and most sustained conflict throughout the history of the United States. Gerstle's angle of vision allows him to illuminate and place in larger context such seemingly diverse events and developments as World War I and multiculturalism, immigration policy and the Christian right, Teddy Roosevelt's reform agenda and the social upheavals of the 1960s. "American Crucible" provides invaluable insight into the shape and structure of contemporary American society through its unique exploration of the nation's past."--Thomas Byrne Edsall, "Washington Post"

"This work confirms Gary Gerstle's stature as one of our most imaginative and ambitious historians. His scholarship substantially redefines the meaning of key ideas about the twentieth-century United States and its culture, including ethnicity, citizenship, patriotism, and Americanism. Gerstle's capacity for revisionism, synthesis, and engaged writing reminds me of Richard Hofstadter, C. Van Woodword, and Warren Sussman. With this book, he enters their league."--Nelson Lichtenstein, University of California, Santa Barbara

"This is one of those rare works of political and cultural history that compel us to rethink the nature and evolution of American society as a whole."--Michael Kazin, Georgetown University

"A bold, provocative, and often disturbing book about the contest between racial and civic definitions of American nationhood. Rarely has a work of scholarship examined the history of racism and exclusion in such comprehensive and dismaying detail, or in such clear and persuasive prose. Gerstle also contributes to the growing interest among historians in the concept of 'whiteness' by closely examining changing views of white ethnicity in the twentieth century. "American Crucible" is an important and impressive book and a major contribution to our understanding of twentieth-century America."--Alan Brinkley, Columbia University

""American Crucible" dramatically portrays the century just past as one in which the United States saw inclusive traditions of civic nationalism compete with and partake of exclusionary racial nationalist traditions. Meticulous research and deep reflection prevent Gerstle from portraying either nationalism as the 'real' American way. The tension between the two and between the author's sober analysis and his strong personal advocacy of civic nationalism produces a remarkable study. Organized accessibly around the nation building projects of the two Roosevelt presidencies, "American Crucible" ranges delightfully from dance halls to the halls of Congress, from comics to picket lines."--David Roediger, Babcock Professor of History, University of Illinois

""American Crucible" is the rare book that utterly transforms the way we view the familiar. With the sweeping yet agile brushstrokes of a great master, Gerstle paints a remarkable new portrait of the American nation on the vast canvas of the twentieth century. Guiding us from Teddy Roosevelt's charge up San Juan Hill to the debacle of Vietnam, he portrays a nation caught between two ideals-what he calls civic and racial nationalism-in constant struggle over whether the essence of American nationhood meant incorporation or exclusion."--Lizabeth Cohen, Harvard University

What people are saying - Write a review

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - Scapegoats - LibraryThing

A very well-written, easy to read examination of US nationalism. Gerstle claims that US nationalism was based on conflicting ideas of civic and racial nationalism. Civic refers to the ideas of ... Read full review

American crucible: race and nation in the twentieth century

User Review  - Not Available - Book Verdict

Beginning with an analysis of Theodore Roosevelt's New Nationalism and Square Deal platforms, historian Gerstle examines how the concepts of race and nation influenced U.S. history in the 20th century ... Read full review

Other editions - View all

Bibliographic information