Autonomy & Paternalism: Reflections on the Theory and Practice of Health Care
Thomas Nys, Yvonne Denier, Toon Vandevelde, T. Vandevelde
Peeters Publishers, 2007 - Medical - 183 pages
In recent years, the triumph of autonomy has made paternalist interventions increasingly problematic. The value of a patient's right to self-determination and the practice of informed consent are considered supremely important in present-day health care ethics. In general, the idea of 'doctor knows best' has become more and more suspicious. This has left us with a situation in which paternalist medicine seems difficult to reconcile with respect for patient autonomy. This book offers a thorough reflection on the relationship between autonomy and paternalism, and argues that, from both theoretical and practical angles, the tension between these concepts is not as acute as it might seem. In long-term care, psychiatry, and care for the severely handicapped, the principle of respect for autonomy is particularly ill-suited. This, however, does not mean that such respect is totally irrelevant, but that it should take a different shape. Good care in those cases requires us to transcend the sharp dichotomy between autonomy and paternalism. In Autonomy and Paternalism: Reflections on the Theory and Practice of Health Care various acclaimed authors present their views on this interesting and extremely relevant debate.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
The Transparent Caring
Autonomy as a Problem for Clinical Ethics
A Defence of Careful Solidarity
Informed Consent and the Grounds of Autonomy
Is Autonomy Relevant to Psychiatric Ethics?
Paternalism as the Expression
Authority and Influence in the Psychotherapeutic Relationship
action actual autonomy agency agent-neutral Agich argue authority auton autonomy and paternalism Autonomy in Long-Term Bioethics Biomedical Ethics Cambridge University Press capacity caregiver carer caring child choices competent concept of autonomy concern context decisions desires doctor Dworkin ethic of care everyday example expertise Frankfurt harm Harm Principle Health human ical ideal implies important incompetent individual informed consent interaction interference Intersexed J.F. Childress J.S. Mill Journal justified Kant Kittay Leuven liberty lives long-term care means medical ethics medical intervention medicine mental Mill moral nalism normative one's Onora O'Neill Oxford University Press parents paternalistic patient autonomy person perspective physical well-being physician preferences principle of respect Principles of Biomedical professional psychiatric psychotherapy question rational reasons regard relationship requires respect for autonomy self-determination self-ownership sense situation social swab Terri Schiavo therapeutic therapists therapy tion transparent treatment understanding value of autonomy World Health Organization York