Before Roe: Abortion Policy in the States
Few issues in contemporary U.S> politics have remained on the public agenda so long and so divisively as abortion policy. The landmark Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Waade, which held that laws prohibiting first trimester abortions were illegal because they violated a woman's right to privacy, still generates heated controversy today, a quarter of a century after it was made. The seeds of that controversy were sown in the seven years immediately preceding Roe, when state legislatures tried to reconcile religious opposition to abortion and individuals' civil liberties.
In this groundbreaking book, Rosemary Nossiff examines the force that shaped abortion policy during those years, and the ways in which states responded to them. To provide in-depth analysis while still looking broadly at the picture, she studies New York, which passed the most permissive abortion bill in the country, and Pennsylvania, which passed one of the most restrictive. That these two states, which share similar demographic, political, and economic characteristics, should reach two such different outcomes provides a perfect case study for observing political dynamics at the state level.
Nossiff examines the medical, religious, and legal discourses employed on both sides of the debate, as well as the role played by feminist discourse. She looks at the role of the political parties in the campaigns, as well as such interest groups as the National Council of Catholic Bishops, the Clergy Consultation Service, the National Organization for Women, and the National Association for the Repeal of Abortion Laws. In addition, she analyzes the strategies used by both sides, as well as partisan and institutionalized developments that facilitated success or failure. Finally, in the Epilogue, she assesses the Roe decision and its aftermath, including an analysis of the pro-life movement in Pennsylvania.
As the author remarks, "Without question people's positions on abortion are shaped by a myriad of social, moral, and economic factors. But ultimately abortion policy is shaped in the political arena. This book examines how one of the most intimate decisions a woman makes, whether to continue or terminate a pregnancy, has become one of the most politicized issues in contemporary American politics.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Reform and Opportunity
Gender Identity and Political Mobilization
Party Politics in New York
InterestGroup Politics in Pennsylvania
Party Discourse and Policy
Other editions - View all
abor abortion activists Abortion Control Act abortion debate abortion policy abortion reform abortion repeal abortion-reform bill access to abortion aligned amendment antiabortion forces birth control Blaine amendment campaign Casey Catholic Conference challenged Chapter Church Committee constitutional contraceptives Cusak decision defeat Dilworth discussion early efforts election Ellen Willis established favor fetus framing strategies grassroots groups Griswold Harrisburg Ibid interest issue Lader Lawrence Lader legislative Leichter ment Milton Shapp mobilize National NYCC opposed Oral History Project organized party system passed PCC's Pennsylvania Philadelphia physicians Planned Parenthood political pre-Roe abortion pre-Roe period pregnancy pro-abortion activists pro-abortion forces pro-choice pro-life forces prohibited protected radical feminists Redstockings reform bill religious repeal bill reproductive Republican restrictive abortion laws right to privacy right-to-life Shapp statute Supreme Court therapeutic abortions tion trimester Vatican II vote Vuitch women women's rights York and Pennsylvania