British Factory, Japanese Factory: The Origins of National Diversity in Industrial Relations

Front Cover
University of California Press, 1990 - History - 467 pages
0 Reviews
The Japanese way of work is notoriously 'different.' But is it Japan or Britain which is the odd man out? This is the first book to explore the real differences, not by contrasting Japanese employment relations with a hazy ideal image of 'the West,” but through a point-by-point comparison of two Japanese factories with two British ones making similar products.

In the first half of the book this comparison is pursued in systematic detail and with vivid illustrations of the attitudes and assumptions which underlie what the author calls the 'market-oriented” system of Britain and the 'organization-oriented' system of Japan. But these descriptions are only the beginning of a broader analysis. One chapter shows how the employment institutions of the two countries fit into their political, family and educational institutions-an exercise in functionalist sociology without the functionalist's usual claim to be so different-dominates the later chapters and these make a major contribution to the discussion of development and of the 'convergence' of different systems.

Are the Japanese being weaned from their 'pre-modern' practices and becoming more like us? On the contrary, Professor Dore finds more signs of our moving in a Japanese direction. The convergence theorists are wrong in taking the market-oriented employment systems created by the peculiarities of nineteenth-century capitalism as necessarily a permanent part of 'modern' industrial relations.



This brings the author to the 'late-development' effect. From a wealth of historical evidence, he argues that Japan's organization-oriented system is not simply a manifestation of Japan's unique culture, nor a hang-over from pre-industrial relations. Late-developers can 'get ahead,' adopting patterns of organization which in older industrial countries are still struggling to break through the crust of nineteenth-century institutions. He supports his thesis with evidence from Asia, Africa, and Latin America. If accepted, its importance for policy in these regions is obvious.

 

What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.

Contents

Abbreviations
18
Who They Are
31
Wages
74
Membership and Organization
114
Mainly England
140
Mainly Japan
163
A Summary
197
Authority Function and Status
222
Some Implications
280
The Japanese Employment System
301
Britain Catching Up?
338
The Origins of the Japanese Employment System
375
Late Development
404
Afterword to the 1990 Edition
421
The Interview Survey
455
Copyright

Two Employment Systems
264

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

References to this book

All Book Search results »

Bibliographic information