Can Africa Export Manufactures?: The Role of Endowment, Exchange Rates and Transaction Costs
World Bank, Development Research Group, Public Economics, 1999 - Capital market - 19 pages
May 1999 - Africa's poor performance in manufactured exports in the 1990s (relative to East Asia) appears to be largely the result of bad policies-especially policies that affect transaction costs. Elbadawi analyzes the determinants of manufactured exports in Africa and other developing countries, guided by three pivotal views on Sub-Saharan Africa's (Africa's) prospects in manufactured exports: ° Adrian Woods holds that Africa cannot have comparative advantage in exports of labor-intensive manufactures (even if broadly defined to include raw material processing) because its natural resources endowment is greater than its human resources endowment (endowment thesis). ° Paul Collier argues that, for most of Africa, unusually high (policy-induced) transaction costs are the main source of Africa's comparative disadvantage in manufactured exports (transaction thesis). ° A third approach (Elbadawi and Helleiner) emphasizes the importance of stable, competitive real exchange rates for profitability of exports in low-income countries (exchange rate-led strategy). Elbadawi tests the implications of these three views with an empirical model of manufactured export performance (manufactured exports' share of GDP), using a panel of 41 countries for 1980-95. His findings: ° Corroborate the predictions of the transaction thesis, in that transaction costs are major determinants of manufactures exports. Investing in reducing these costs generates the highest payoff for export capacity. ° Lend support for the exchange rate-led strategy. After controlling for other factors, ratios of natural resources per worker were not robustly associated with export performance across countries, but this cannot be taken as formal rejection of the endowment thesis - unless one is prepared to assume that manufactured exports' share of GDP was highly correlated with ratios of manufactured to aggregate (or primary) exports. But this is not unlikely. This paper-a product of Public Economics, Development Research Group-is part of a larger effort in the group to research manufactures exports' competitiveness. The author may be contacted at email@example.com.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
advantage in exports Africa's comparative African countries aggregate investment aggregate or primary area per 100 associated with manufactured Burkina Faso COEFF comparative advantage competitiveness corroborated Cote d'Ivoire determinants of manufactured developing countries Dummy East Asia effect on manufactured Elbadawi and Helleiner endowment thesis estimating exchange rate misalignment exchange rate policy exchange rate variability export diversification exports to GDP Exports/GDP fax machines global Growth Rate 84-95 human capital Indonesia J’AFR Kenya Labor Ratio labor-intensive manufactured land area length of paved levels Malaysia manufactured export performance manufactured export/GDP Mauritius MNEX shares MNEX to GDP MNEX/GDP natural resource endowment number of fax panel of 41 paved roads Policy Research ratio of manufactured ratio of schooling real exchange rate RERMIS Research Working Paper Rodrik shares of MNEX skills ratios South Africa sustainable T-STAT Table 1.B Tanzania terms of trade Thailand three views transaction costs transaction theory Tunisia William Easterly World Bank Zimbabwe