Comparative Justice: Civil Jury Verdicts in San Francisco and Cook Counties, 1959-1980
In this report, the authors describe San Francisco jury trials and jury verdicts during the 20-year period from 1960 through 1979, and compare trends and patterns with those found in Cook County, Illinois. The data describe approximately 5,300 civil cases that were tried before juries in San Francisco County. These are then compared with an earlier study of Cook County civil jury trials. The study suggests that there is reasonable similarity in jury decisions over time and in different places. Although these results provide reassurance about juries, the frequency of these low-stakes cases raises questions about the economics of the civil justice system. However, most of the jury trials studied are probably economically justified for the parties. Although the analyses in this report cannot explain why, there was one important change in jury verdicts in both jurisdictions--the size of the largest awards. The size of the largest awards grew sharply in both jurisdictions. In both studies the authors found a general stability and consistency in jury decisions over time and across jurisdictions.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
OVERVIEW OF CIVIL TRIALS
TRENDS IN CIVIL JURY TRIALS AND VERDICTS
EFFECTS OF COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE
1 other sections not shown
50 percent 90th percentile actions analysis auto accident average award awards in Cook awards in San awards increased business torts California CD CD cisco civil jury trials common carrier comparative negligence rule contract and business Contracts/business contributory negligence Cook County plaintiffs Court creased decreased defendants Dramshop early expected award Francisco and Cook frequently injury on property intentional tort trials issues jurisdictions jurors jury awards jury decisions Jury Verdict Reporter Jury Verdicts Weekly large awards largest awards late lawsuits Long-Term Trends low-stakes malpractice awards medical malpractice million dollar awards money awarded negligent plaintiffs number of trials parties Peterson and Priest PLAINTIFF AWARDS plaintiff victories plaintiffs won product liability proportion of plaintiff proportion of trials rH rH rH San Fran San Francisco Cook San Francisco County San Francisco juries second-action Street hazard third-party total awards trials in Cook trials in San trials involving U.S. District Court winning worker injury trials