Department for Business, Innovation and Skills: venture capital support to small businesses, seventeenth report of session 2009-10, report, together with formal minutes, oral and written evidence
The Stationery Office, Mar 9, 2010 - Business & Economics - 33 pages
Since 2000 the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (the Department) and its predecessors have invested public money, alongside private investors, in a series of funds managed by private sector fund managers. The funds provide support to small businesses unlikely to receive support from other sources. The programme currently comprises 28 funds. By December 2009 taxpayers had contributed £338 million, alongside £438 million from private investors. The Department's intervention in the venture capital market was experimental and risky, yet it did not set clear, prioritised objectives for the funds, including the expected economic benefits, and did not set targets at the outset for expected rates of return. The Department did not begin to properly evaluate the progress of its early funds until late 2008 and, to the concern of the Committee, did not publish any information on the funds until December 2009. The evidence suggests that the funds are underperforming. As at December 2008 the Regional Venture Capital Funds, the largest category of early funds, showed negative returns and the average rate of return was minus 15.7 per cent whilst private European venture capital funds of a similar size had an average rate of return of minus 0.4 per cent. The Department has not done enough to curtail the high costs of managing the funds. Fees for the Regional Venture Capital Funds have totalled £46 million compared to the £130 million invested. Substantial fees have been paid to fund managers even though the performance of the funds has been poor.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
13 January aid rules Austin Mitchell Bacon C&AG's Report Capital for Enterprise Chairman Committee of Public companies Comptroller and Auditor Department for Business Douglas Carswell Earley early funds economic Enterprise Capital Funds Enterprise Limited equity gap exits fees paid Felda Hardymon figure financial performance Fraser Fund Investments fund sizes Geraldine Smith going grants to business Harvard Business School Innovation and Skills interim evaluation Investment Fund January 2010 Department Josh Lerner large number learned lessons Midven Mitchell MP Conservative MP Labour national programmes Nigel Griffiths paras Partnership portfolio private investors private sector investors Public Accounts rate of return RDAs Regional Development Agencies Regional Venture Capital Richard Bacon risk RVCF schemes ScriptSwitch set clear Skills and Capital small businesses SME Finance South East Squire structure successful support to small taxpayer Total raised value for money Venture Capital Funds Venture capital support Wednesday 13