Developing Quality Dissertations in the Sciences: A Graduate Student's Guide to Achieving Excellence
This is one of three short booklets designed to be given to graduate students as they begin their studies.
They explain the purposes of the dissertation and the criteria by which it will be assessed. They help students understand the context of their course work; the need to take an active role in shaping their studies; and the importance of thinking ahead about the components of the dissertation and the quality of scholarship they will need to demonstrate.
These booklets are intended to support the dissertation research and writing process by providing faculty and advisors with guidelines for setting clear expectations for student performance, and with a model for helping students produce the desired quality of work.
They encourage dialogue between faculty and students about the quality of the components of their dissertation project. They include rubrics that students can use to self-assess their work and that can aid faculty in providing focused feedback.
Setting explicit targets and benchmarks of excellence of the sort advocated in these booklets will enable departments and universities to respond to demands for accountability with clear criteria for, and evidence of, success; and will raise the overall quality of student performance.
What people are saying - Write a review
1 Identifying the Purpose of the Dissertation
2 Understanding Originality and Significance
3 Aiming for Excellence in the Dissertation
4 Maintaining Consistent Quality Within the Dissertation
5 Achieving Excellence
Appendix A Tasks of the Science Engineering and Mathematics Dissertation
Appendix B Advice for Writing a Science Dissertation
About the Study
Acceptable Unacceptable advance the ﬁeld advisor and committee applying approach appropriate argument Ask your advisor booklet cite clear clearly committee members concisely connections correct critical deﬁned developing Different Quality Levels difﬁcult discipline discipline’s Discussion and Conclusion Dissertation at Different Dissertation by Quality dissertation demonstrates Electrical and Computer explain Faculty in Biology faculty members feedback ﬁnd ﬁndings graduate students hypotheses ideas identiﬁes Identify important insightful Introduction/Problem Statement knowledge Levels 000 Table Mathematics 000 Table Mathematics Biology Mathematics Dissertation ments misses moves the ﬁeld organized original and signiﬁcant original contribution original or signiﬁcant Outstanding dissertations papers presentation problem in context profes proof provide a context Provide enough detail Quality Levels 000 Quality Levels Outstanding question or problem relevant research question scientiﬁc sertation shows signiﬁcant contribution skills solid solve speciﬁc summary synthesizes tasks tation theoretical theory(ies things ticulate tion understand writing wrong