Exegesis as Polemical Discourse: Ibn Ḥazm on Jewish and Christian Scriptures
In the history of relations among Islam, Christianity, and Judaism, the encounter in medieval Spain stands out as particularly noteworthy for its intensity and creativity. This interaction generated many polemical texts presenting the competing claims of the three monotheistic faiths. One such text is the Treatise on Obvious Contradictions and Evident Lies, by the Muslim scholar Abu Mudhammad 'Ali ibn Hazm al-Andalusi (d. 1064). This study makes the content of the Treatise available to English speakers for the first time, providing a detailed description of the work and an assessment of its significance. Theodore Pulcini argues that Ibn Hazm's polemical biblical exegesis is best understood within the centuries-old tradition in which Muslim authors evaluated the Jewish and Christian scriptures. Analyzing the historical and sociocultural dynamics of eleventh-century Islamic Spain, he contends that Ibn Hazm wrote the Treatise for the purpose of effecting societal reform.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
IBN HAZMS LIFE AND WORK
THE TREATISE ON CONTRADICTIONS AND LIES
Works of the Eighth and Ninth Centuries C E
Ibn Rabbans Book of Religion and Empire and Refutation
Works of the Tenth and Eleventh Centuries C E
IBN HAZMS CRITIQUE OF THE TORAH
Blasphemy against Christ as Prophet
Contradictions within Gospels
Texts That Escaped Corruption
IBN HAZMS CHARACTERIZATION OF JEWS
Other editions - View all
absurd accept according to Ibn Adang adversary al-Andalus al-Tabari Andalusian Arabic argument Arpachshad Asin-Palacios asserts attributed authentic Berber Bible biblical text Book C6rdoba caliph century Chapter Chejne Christ Christian scriptures Christian Texts claims consider Contradictions and Lies corruption Critique depicted dhimmis disciples doctrine earlier scriptures Egypt error example Exegesis as Polemical falsehood father Furthermore hadith Hazm's Hebrew Hebrew Bible Ibn Hazm Ibn Hazm argues Ibn Hazm asks Ibn Hazm concludes Ibn Hazm notes Ibn Khallikan Ibn Nagrela Ibn Qutayba Ibn Rabban interpretation Islam Israel Israelites Jacob Jesus Jewish and Christian Jewish scriptures Jewish Texts Jews and Christians John Judah king Literary Context Matthew Metatron Mingana miracles Moses Muhammad Muslims non-Muslims passages pericope Polemical Discourse Polemical Process polemicist political prophet prophethood Qur'an religion rhetoric rulers schismogenesis specific tahrif Talmud teaching Testament textual Torah trans Treatise on Contradictions truth Umayyad Vulgate Zahiri