In Words and Deeds: Battle Speeches in History

Front Cover
UPNE, 2008 - History - 424 pages
0 Reviews
Throughout recorded military history, leaders have persuaded men to risk life and limb for God, country, unit, comrades, and families; for plunder, vengeance, glory, a lasting peace, or new conquests. Beginning with the holy wars of the Hebrew Bible and continuing to the present Iraq conflict, one constant motivator of men in war has been the battle speech: the exhortatory words uttered by commanders on the eve of invasions and before, during, after, and between battles.

In Greco-Roman times, battle speeches, as recorded (or invented) by historians such as Herodotus, Thucydides, and Livy were considered literary creations of a high order. In the centuries that followed, both biblical and Greco-Roman narratives established the templates that have influenced military exhortations to the present day. Emotions inspired by the battle speech might be universal, but conceptions of God, the rules of war, and the proper objects of warfare have evolved to reflect changes in cultural norms, military organization, and technology.

Richard F. Miller offers the first systemic classification of battle speeches while exploring how their contents have changed over time. Speeches are classified based on their chronological relation to the battle or tactical circumstance the speaker seeks to address. In many situations, deeds accompany words in a continuum of action that renders both action and words inseparable. Thus, Miller often analyzes both components in a battle sequence.

In Words and Deeds relies chiefly on primary texts written either by soldier-participants, or, in the case of the Hebrew Bible and certain Greco-Roman accounts, the most important surviving texts of the ancient wars. For modern European and American military history, the sources are almost exclusively first-hand accounts contained in soldiers’ diaries, letters, after-action reports, and memoirs. Secondary sources are used to extract first-hand accounts of words and deeds or to support conclusions about how such speeches have evolved.
 

What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.

Contents

Introduction
1
What Really Was Said or Done?
12
Durable Appeals
20
The History in Battle Speeches
27
The Presentation and the Recruiting Speech
65
Instructional Speech
104
Deeds as Instructional Speech
138
PreInvasion Speeches
145
The Word and the Deed
231
Telling a Story
276
Assuming Command
317
The Final Victory Speech
349
Epilogue
356
Notes
367
Bibliography
397
Index
407

PreBattle Speeches
186

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2008)

RICHARD F. MILLER is the author of Harvard s Civil War: The History of the Twentieth Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry (2005) and A Carrier At War: On Board the USS Kitty Hawk in the Iraq War (2005) and co-author (with Robert F. Mooney) of The Civil War: The Nantucket Experience (1994). A Fellow of the Massachusetts Historical Society, Miller is a graduate of Harvard and Case Western Reserve University School of Law.

Bibliographic information