Judging Oil Spill Response Performance: The Challenge of Competing Perspectives
American Petroleum Institute, 1999 - Oil pollution of rivers, harbors, etc - 52 pages
"The history of judging spill response documents the early default criterion in the 1970s-remove visible oil-that evolved into ecologically based criteria in the 1980s-minimize spill impacts and protect environmentally sensitive areas. In the aftermath of the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill, more stakeholders and more criteria entered the spill response process in the 1990s. Each stakeholder is concerned with receiving favorable media coverage, or at least minimizing negative coverage, and often views the media as final judges of response performance. The many stakeholders and their many, sometimes conflicting, criteria for judging response are examined, and factors that promote or impede response success are identified. Recommendationa are made to develop response goals and criteria acceptable to all stakeholders in advance of a spill incident. These critieria can then be used to develop contingency and response plans focused on achieving the goals and objectives of all stakeholders. Response performance can then be measured against those criteria either by the response community during exercises and routine responses or an independent panel in the aftermath of a major incident. These evaluations, using stakeholder criteria, can be returned to stakeholders for their consideration in either adjusting criteria that are proven impractical or revising plans to better meet the criteria. Recommendations are offerted to foster debate and are aimed at establishing a standard mechanism for repsonse performance measurement and ultimately improvement"--Abstract.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
The Stakeholders and Their Criteria for Assessing Performance
Forces That Promote or Impede Performance
3 other sections not shown
1997 International Oil 25 June American Petroleum Institute Angeles assess performance assess spill response Assessing response performance beach Braer Buffalo 292 citizens groups Coast Guard contingency plans developed ecological impacts elected officials environmental groups environmental impacts etal Exxon Valdez spill factors that promote formance government agencies Houston Chronicle Huntington Beach identified impede performance improve independent panel industry International Maritime Organization International Oil Spill involved judging spill response large spills Lindstedt-Siva major spills Managers Managers Managers mance measures ment minimize Oil Spill Conference Oil Spill Response operations specialists performance criteria planning process Proceedings psss Ott recommendations response community response decision response effort response goals response operations response organization response process response strategies Santa Barbara scientists Sea Empress sensitive areas shoreline cleanup spill event spill experts spill impacts spill managers spill response performance Spill Response Planning spilled oil spiller stakeholders tanker tions Torrey Canyon Washington Post