Justice, liability, and blame: community views and the criminal law
Drafters of legal codes often implicitly or explicitly seek to incorporate community standards. To what extent have they succeeded? This book examines shared intuitive notions of justice among laypersons and compares the discovered principles to those intantiated in current American criminal codes. After discussion of the proper role of community views in formulating legal doctrine, Robinson and Darley report eighteen original studies on a wide range of issues in dispute among legal theorists. The authors compare lay institutions and code provisions on such questions as the justified use of force, insanity, causation, complicity, risk-creation, omission liability, culpability requirements, duress, entrapment, multiple offenses, and criminalization matters such as felony murder and sexual offenses. Many important differences between the legal code and community views are found, and the authors discuss the implications of thosedifferences. One implication is the possibility that such conflicts could lead to reduced compliance as the code loses its moral authority with the community.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Community Standards and the Criminal Law
What Conduct Should Be Criminal?
When Should It Be Lawful for One
25 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
accomplice actor Alex arrest assault assume the following attacker attempt aware blameworthy Brian causing death Characteristic Chris cocaine code drafters Code's cognitive coin column commit community standards community's views control dysfunction convicted crime criminal codes criminal law criminal liability culpability requirements deadly force decides defense defense of property degree doctrine Down's Syndrome Faultless felony fense formulation function grading Gregory harm husband individual insanity insanity defense intuitions judge judgments jury kill knows legal codes liability and punishment liability assigned manslaughter Mark and Pete Mary Mike Model Penal Code moral murder narios negligent oil drum owner perceived percent perpetrator person person's conduct poison pre-intoxication rape reasonable reckless respondents risk rob the safe robbery roommate scenarios self-defense sentence sexual intercourse shoot spousal rape statutory rape steal stun gun subjects substantial suggests Suzanne Table theft tion Vic will drown victim violation