METHODS IN MEDICAL ETHICS: Critical Perspectives
Over the last several decades, bioethicists have championed a bewildering variety of methods for understanding and resolving difficult ethical problems in medicine, including: principlism, wide reflective equilibrium, casuistry, feminism, virtue theory, narrative, and others. Much of this advocacy overlooks the limitations of the favored method, and also neglects the strengths found in alternative approaches. Tom Tomlinson systematically uncovers and evaluates both the strengths and limits of a variety of ethical tools, and in so doing develops a comprehensive appreciation of the roles that various methods can play in deepening our understanding of ethical problems in medicine, and in supporting well-grounded judgments about what to do. He critically evaluates each method to identify both limits and advantages, which he then illustrates through discussion of specific cases and controversies. Tomlinson not only demonstrates that there is no single method adequate to the task, but tries to develop an informed eclecticism that knows how to pick the right tool for the right job. All those engaged in thinking about bioethical theories will find Tomlinson's work important reading.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
abortion abstract alternative altruism answer appeal argue argument by analogy assisted suicide balancing judgments Beauchamp and Childress Bioethics casuistical casuistry chapter choices circumstances claim coherence model concerned conclusion conflict considered judgments Consuela context critical Dancy decision discussion duty Engelhardt epistemic ethic of care euthanasia evaluation example fact Feminism feminist ethics fetus Gert inference interpretation intuition Irene’s Jehovah’s Witness Jonsen and Toulmin justification killing maxims medical ethics ment method moral judgment Moral Particularism moral principles moral reasoning morally relevant motives narrative ethics Nelson norm offer one’s organ donation paradigm paradigmatic particular particular judgments patient Pellegrino and Thomasma person physician practice principle of permission principle of utility principle-based question refuse rely requires Richardson role Sherwin Singer social sort specific standpoint theory story tion tive Tomlinson treatment universalizability University Press utilitarian virtue ethics virtue theory warrant wide reflective equilibrium women wrong