Making Elite Lawyers: Visions of Law at Harvard and Beyond
Harvard Law School is more than a law school; it's a cultural icon. Home to the best and the brightest, training ground for the corporate elite. Surprisingly enough, however, an overwhelming majority of students in any entering class identifies itself as liberal to leftist in its political orientation. Then why does the majority of any graduating class choose corporate law practice over public interest work? What happens to students in those three years between orientation and commencement?
Making Elite Lawyers is the first detailed study of legal education at America's premier law school. Drawing on in-depth interviews, student questionnaires, and his own classroom observations, author Robert Granfield documents the conservatizing effects of the Harvard legal education on a broad cross-section of the student population, paying particular attention to the fate of women, students of color, and those from working-class backgrounds at Harvard Law School. In his analysis of the legal curriculum, Granfield shows how the boot-camp of first-year law school marks the emergence of a finely-tuned legal consciousness which comes to value gamesmanship over ideals, and competition and victory over right and wrong. As learning to "think like a lawyer" begins to take its toll on students - leaving them confused and alienated by this legal education - students are forced to pragmatically conclude that their moral beliefs are a thing apart from their work as attorneys.
Making Elite Lawyers reveals how the "Harvard Mystique" also helps conservatize students. From the moment they arrive on campus for orientation to the manner in which they are wined and dined as summer associate candidates by top-flight corporate law firms, students are encouraged to accept the status, power, and money that the Harvard Law School experience confers. By offering students the psychological and material path of least resistance into America's higher circles, Granfield concludes, Harvard ultimately only schools its attorneys to represent the interests of the social and political status quo.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
American Legal Education
The Moral Transformation
5 other sections not shown
accept activities American arguments associated attending background become believe career collective commented commitment competent concern consciousness considered construct contribute critical culture decision described develop discussion dominant don't effective elite entered experience experienced explained expressed fact feel felt first-year forms gender graduates greater groups Harvard Law Review Harvard Law School Harvard law students ideals identity ideological important individuals instance institutions interviews involved issues It's large firm law firms law students lawyers legal education legal practice legal profession less lives male Northeastern offered opportunities orientation particularly percent political position practice Press problems produce professional public interest public interest law radical reasons relation reported represents resistance role second-year sense social change social justice society status things third-year student thought tool University values views women working-class students York