Noncitizen Voting and American Democracy

Front Cover
Rowman & Littlefield, 2009 - Law - 135 pages
Continuing large-scale migration to the United States raises the question of how best to integrate new immigrants into the American national community. Traditionally, one successful answer has been to encourage immigrants to learn our language, culture, history, and civic traditions. New immigrants would then be invited become citizens and welcomed as full members of the community. However, a concerted effort is underway to gain acceptance for, and implement, the idea that the United States should allow new immigrants to vote without becoming citizens. It is mounted by an alliance that brings together progressive academics, law professors, local and state political leaders, and community activists, all working to decouple voting from American citizenship. Their effort show signs of success, but is it really in America's best interests to allow new immigrants to have the vote? Their proposals have been much advocated, but little analyzed. Neither a polemic nor a whitewash, Stanley A. Renshon provides a careful analysis of the arguments put forward by advocates of this position on the basis of fairness, increasing democracy, civic learning, and moral necessity and asks: Do they really help immigrants become Americans?
 

What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.

Contents

Allowing New Noncitizen Immigrants to Vote Framing the Issues
1
A Range of Proposals
19
Impact Administrative Complexities Holding Office and Progressive Politics
33
Evaluating Proposals to Allow Noncitizen Voting Steps to a More Useful Discussion
47
History Legality and Bandwagons
69
Iconic Claims Contrary Evidence
87
In Defense of Naturalization
105
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2009)

Stanley A. Renshon is professor of political science at the City University of New York Graduate Center. He is the author of over ninety articles and fourteen books and is a certified psychoanalyst.

Bibliographic information