Pornography Embodied: From Speech to Sexual Practice
What does it mean to conceptualize pornography as a material practice rather than as speech? Mason-Grant argues that this idea, fundamental to the work of Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon, has been obscured in legal wrangling and political polarization over their civil ordinance. Within the arena of legal argument, where the principle of free speech holds sway for progressive thinkers, their analysis of pornography is rendered, at worse, an apology for censorship and, at best, an argument about the social force of speech, rather than recognized as a fundamental challenge to the very idea of pornography as speech. In this book, Mason-Grant first shows how the persistent 'speech paradigm' inevitably obscures the innovative core of the Dworkin-MacKinnon critique of mainstream pornography. She then develops an alternative 'practice paradigm' that critically engages their analysis, capturing and extending its core insights about the role of pornography in sexual practice. Drawing on phenomenology of the lived body, this alternative paradigm provides a way of re-thinking how the pervasive use of mass-market heterosexual pornography contributes to the cultivation of an embodied and tacit sexual know-how that is subordinating, and raises important questions about alternative materials produced and used by sexual minorities. In her conclusion, Mason-Grant considers the implications of her analysis not for law, but for a critical pedagogy in youth sexuality education.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Pornography as a Systemic Practice of Subordination
Equality Speech and Pornography
The Subordination of Pornography as Illocutionary Force
Bodily Practices and the Production of Tacit KnowHow
The Use of Pornography as a Subordinating Practice
Other editions - View all
Absent Body act of apartheid analysis of pornography Andrea Dworkin apartheid argued argument Butler decision Catharine MacKinnon child pornography claim that pornography conceptual constitutive context corporeal Cossman and Bell critical cultural discourse domination and subordination Dworkin and MacKinnon’s emphasis engage Excitable Speech experience Feminism Feminism Unmodified feminist force forms of sexual Foucault Francis Biddle’s Sister free speech gender harm ideas illocutionary act illocutionary force illocutions inequality irreducibly Judith Butler Langton Larry Flynt Law Cambridge Leder liberal liberty lived body MacKinnon and Dworkin MacKinnon’s analysis mainstream pornography male means moral normalizing obscenity law one’s oppression ordinance phenomenological photograph political pornog pornogra pornographic materials pornography for sex principle of equality produced prostitution raphy reiterative Ronald Dworkin sexual arousal sexual desire sexual norms sexual practices sexually explicit Shannon Bell social norms social power speech act theory speech paradigm structure tacit tion transformation violence women words and images