The Concept of Justice: Is Social Justice Just?
In The Concept of Justice, Patrick Burke explores and argues for a return to traditional ideas of ordinary justice in opposition to conceptions of 'social justice' that came to dominate political thought in the 20th Century. Arguing that our notions of justice have been made incoherent by the radical incompatibility between instinctive notions of ordinary justice and theoretical conceptions of social justice, the book goes on to explore the historical roots of these ideas of social justice. Finding the roots of these ideas in religious circles in Italy and England in the 19th century, Burke explores the ongoing religious influence in the development of the concept in the works of Marx, Mill and Hobhouse. In opposition to this legacy of liberal thought, the book presents a new theory of ordinary justice drawing on the thought of Immanuel Kant. In this light, Burke finds that all genuine ethical evaluation must presuppose free will and individual responsibility and that all true injustice is fundamentally coercive.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
action Adam Smith affairs in society Antonio Rosmini argued argument Aristotle Barry believe Catholic Catholic social teaching chapter choice Christian Christian Socialists citizens Civil Rights Act coercion coercive discrimination Communist conception of justice conception of social consequences considered constitution contract created Declaration demands deserve dignity doctrine economic employer encyclical equality ethical example existence fact force freedom Gaudium et spes harm Hegel Human Rights Ibid idea imputed individual responsibility inequality interior judgment justice and injustice Kant kind labor Leo’s liberal liberty Mater et magistra Matteo Liberatore means mens rea Mingardi moral nations nature objective one’s ordinary justice ownership peaceful discrimination person philosophy Pius political poor possess poverty principle prohibition punishment Quadragesimo anno question reason redistribution Rerum novarum respect Rosmini sense social justice Taparelli term theory thing traditional true U.S. Constitution universal unjust virtue wages workers