The Words of Selves: Identification, Solidarity, Irony
Marlene Dietrich had the last line in Orson Welles's A Touch of Evil: "What does it matter what you say about other people?" The author ponders the question: What does it matter what you say about yourself? She wonders why the requirement to be a something-or-other should be so hard to satisfy in a manner that rings true in the ears of its own subject. She decides that some hesitations and awkwardness in inhabiting many categories of the person including those celebrated by what is sometimes termed identity politics need not evidence either psychological weakness or political lack of nerve.
Neither an "identity" nor a "nonidentity" can quite convince. But if this discomfort inhering in self-characterization needs to be fully admitted and registered as something that is simultaneously linguistic and affective it can also be cheerfully tolerated. Here language is not treated as a guileful thing that leads its speakers astray. Though the business of being called something, and of being positioned by that calling, is often an unhappy affair, irony can offer effective therapy. Even if uncertain and volatile categorizations do trouble the politics that they also shape, they hardly weaken the empathetic solidarity that is distinct from identification. The verbal irony of self-presentation can be politically helpful. Questioning the received diction of the self cannot be dismissed merely as a luxury of those in secure positions, but instead can move toward a conception of a constructive nonidentity.
This extended meditation on the language of the self within contemporary social politics also considers the lyrical "I" and linguistic emotionality, the historical status of irony, and the possibilities of a nonidentitarian solidarity that is unapologetically alert to the affect of language.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
already appear attributes become better Books called carry chapter claim clear close collectivity comes common concept critical dead designation direction Echo effect emotion ethical example expression fact fall feel follow force give grammar guilt hand hope idea identification identity individual instance interpellation ironic irony it's kind language least less linguistic live Logic London look lyric marks means metaphor nature never Nietzsche notion object offer once original performance perhaps person poetry political position possess possible practice present produced psychology question refuse remains responsibility result rhetorical seems self-description sense simply social solidarity someone sound speak speaker speech strange structure temporality term there's thing thought tion trans truth turn unconscious University Press utterance verbal voice whole wound writing