Understanding history: an introduction to analytical philosophy of history
Has any question about the historical past ever been finally answered? Of course there is much disagreement among professional historians about what happened in the past and how to explain it. But this incisive study goes one step further and brings into question the very ability of historians to gather and communicate genuine knowledge about the past. Understanding Historyapplies this general question from the philosophy of history to economic history of American slaveholders. Do we understand the American slaveholders? Has the last word on the subject been said? Both the alleged "profitability" of slavery and the purported causes of the American Civil War are philosophically analyzed. Traditional narrative history and econometric history are examined and compared, and their different philosophical assumptions made explicit. The problem of justifying historical methodologies is first set in the wider context of the philosophical problem of knowledge, then lucidly explained and resolved along pragmatic lines. The novelty of Gorman's approach lies in its comparison of narrative with econometric history, its analysis of empathetic understanding in terms of cost-benefit analysis, and its elucidation of the metaphysical presuppositions of empiricism. It stands out especially for the clarity, rigor, and simplicity of its arguments.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Traditional History 5976
2 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
achieving knowledge action adopted American analytic statement answer approach to history argument beliefs cause chapter choice cliometric approach committed commodity bundle Conrad's and Meyer's cost-benefit analysis cost-benefit calculation counterfactual conditional covering law theory desires econometric economic theory empathetic understanding empathize empirical empiricism empiricist example exist expressed false Fogel and Engerman follows given Hempel historians historical knowledge historical writing Hume idea of causation independent individual interpretation involved issue J. L. Mackie justification kind of entity kinds of thing logical matter means metaphysical assumptions moral narrative notion objects Oxford University Press person Philadelphia conference philosophy of economics philosophy of history possible posteriori preference priori problem problem of induction purpose question was slavery R. G. Collingwood rational economic reason regularity requires rience sense slave slaveholders slavery profitable social Stampp's storylike suppose synthetic statement theorist traditional approach traditional metaphysics truth understood universal statement warranted