Unequal Peers: The Politics of Discourse Management in the Social Sciences
Peer review plays an important role in academic practice. By definition, it implies a frank and equal intellectual exchange between scholars with similar capabilities. But does this happen in practice? And what are the consequences? Among other things, peer review regulates who gets published in academic journals - and who doesn't. In this provocative book, the author examines whether the peer review process meets these expectations in practice. She does so by publishing three essays which she submitted to academic journals, and were rejected, together with comments by the (anonymous) reviewers, and their subsequent correspondence. In an accompanying analysis, she finds that, far from maintaining equality between reviewer and reviewed, the peer review process is dominated by scholars allied to Western models of knowledge production, who use their 'gateway' positions to marginalise and discourage African schools of thought. Trenchantly, she concludes that, in its current guise, peer review is encouraging 'dwarfed knowledge production', and hampering its transformation in South Africa and elsewhere.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Chapter 1 Where the local meets the global
Chapter 2 From Shepston to Mufamadi
Chapter 3 The Secular Dynamics of Traditional Leadership in KwaZuluNatal South Africa
academic administrative African existentialism African scholarship African social science amakhosi analysis analytical Anthropology apartheid Appadurai argues argument basic beneﬁt boundaries challenge chiefdoms colonial concepts context councillors cultural deal debate deﬁne deﬁnition demarcation democracy democratic difﬁcult discourse economic eThekwini existence fact ﬁnd ﬁrst global government practice groups historical human ideal individual identity ideology impact Indigenous Knowledge inﬂuence inkosi institution intellectual issues Journal key performance indicators knowledge production KwaZulu-Natal land reform Mamdani Marxism Mfecane Municipal Systems Act Natal Nguni notion objectivism objectivity ofﬁcials paper paradigms particular peer reviewers people’s perspective Pietermaritzburg political problem question recognise reﬂect relationship rural areas scholars schools of thought scientiﬁc sector self-actualisation Shepstone Sithole social actor social scientists social unit South Africa space speciﬁc stiﬂed structures subjectivity sufﬁcient Theophilus Shepstone traditional authority traditional leaders traditional leadership ubuntu University of KwaZulu-Natal urban areas Western Zululand