Beyond Cheering and Bashing: New Perspectives on the Closing of the American Mind
William K. Buckley, James Seaton
Popular Press, 1992 - Education - 166 pages
The debate over the central issue confronted in Closing--the role of the university and the liberal arts in the United States--has become increasingly urgent and contentious. The goal of this collection of essays is to consider what we can learn about the dilemmas confronting American culture through a consideration of both The Closing of the American Mind and the debate it has aroused. The contributors differ among themselves as to the validity of both the diagnoses and the solutions Bloom offers, yet they do not engage in "Bloom-bashing" or hero-worship. The goal of the book is to place the debate over Closing into the larger context than can be achieved in a book review format. To provide the historical perspective that has been missing in the controversy over Bloom, included in this volume is Christopher Lasch's "The Great Experiment: Where Did it Go Wrong?" Also included are essays by other leading critics: John K. Roth, Frank Caucci, William K. Buckley, Milton R. Stern, Susan Bourgeois, Margaret C. Jones, Daniel Zins, Kenneth Alan Hovey, Bonnie A. Hain, John Peacock, Patricia L. Lundberg, Peter Siedlecki, Mark W. Roche, William Thickstun, Lorraine Clark, and Gerald Graff. This volume of essays does much to illuminate the issue surrounding The Closing of the American Mind.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Where Did It Go Wrong?
The Good the Bad and the Ugly in Amerikas Akademia
Strange Bedfellows and their Offspring
A Feminist Reads The Closing of the American Mind
A Bloom Amid the ReaganBushes
The Great Books vs America
An American Tale
Arbiters of Culture
Allan Bloom and the Limits of Reason
On Mimesis as Freedom
Other editions - View all
academic according to Bloom Allan Bloom American Mind argues argument attack become believe Bloomland canon claims classical Closing conflict contemporary criticism Cultural Literacy cultural relativism debate Democracy and Impoverished democratic discourse E.D. Hirsch Education Has Failed example fact Failed Democracy feminism feminist fiction Gerald Graff German Glaucon Graff Higher Education Hirsch historicism Horace Mann human ideal ideas Impoverished the Souls intellectual jeremiad knowledge Lasch liberal literary study literature live Lysias male Mann's Marx McCarthyism modern moral nature Nietzsche nihilism norms nuclear objectivity Phaedrus philosophy Plato poetry political possible prejudices principles problems questions reader reason relativism Republic rhetoric rock music Rousseau Saul Bellow sexism sexual skepticism social society Socrates Solway Souls of Today's teacher teaching theory things thinkers thought Today's Students tradition truth Wollstonecraft women writes York young