Whose Justice? Which Rationality?Is there any cause or war worth risking one's life for? How can we determine which actions are vices and which virtues? MacIntyre, professor of philosophy at Vanderbilt University, unravels these and other such questions by linking the concept of justice to what he calls practical rationality. He rejects the grab-what-you-can, utilitarian yardstick adopted by moral relativists. Instead, he argues that four wholly different, incompatible ideas of justice put forth by Aristotle, Augustine, Aquinas and Hume have helped shape our modern individualistic world. In his unorthodox view, each person seeks the good through an ongoing dialogue with one of these traditions or within Jewish, non-Western or other historical traditions. This weighty sequel to After Virtue (1981) is certain to stir debate. |
From inside the book
Results 1-3 of 25
Page 65
... Thucydides ' own standpoint in relation to the events about which he wrote his history . Three features of that standpoint are crucial . First , Thucydides sepa- rates arete and intelligence , a separation apparent in the contrasting ...
... Thucydides ' own standpoint in relation to the events about which he wrote his history . Three features of that standpoint are crucial . First , Thucydides sepa- rates arete and intelligence , a separation apparent in the contrasting ...
Page 66
... Thucydides ' narrative of the closing episodes of the Athenian disaster at Syracuse . But the harsh necessity of which Euripides speaks in that chorus is the necessity of the cosmic order . Writing of the Trojan Women , Hugh Lloyd ...
... Thucydides ' narrative of the closing episodes of the Athenian disaster at Syracuse . But the harsh necessity of which Euripides speaks in that chorus is the necessity of the cosmic order . Writing of the Trojan Women , Hugh Lloyd ...
Page 70
... Thucydides about what actually happens . What people generally take to be justice is indeed what the strong make it . And justice , rightly understood , requires a type of polis which it is ex- tremely improbable that anyone will be ...
... Thucydides about what actually happens . What people generally take to be justice is indeed what the strong make it . And justice , rightly understood , requires a type of polis which it is ex- tremely improbable that anyone will be ...
Contents
Rival Justices Competing Rationalities | 1 |
Justice and Action in the Homeric Imagination | 12 |
The Division of the PostHomeric Inheritance | 30 |
Copyright | |
18 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
Common terms and phrases
able account of justice achieve action adequate allegiance appeal Aquinas aretē argued argument Aristotelian Aristotle Aristotle's asserted Athenian Athens Augustinian beliefs Book central century Cicero claims conception of justice conclusion conflict confronted context course culture debate dialectical disagreement divine earlier embodied evaluation excellence expression fundamental Gorgias Greek Homeric human Hume Hume's Humean Hutcheson incompatible individual insofar intellectual Isocrates judge judgments kind language liberal ment modern modes moral philosophy moral sense nature Neoptolemus Nicomachean Ethics Odysseus one's particular passions Periclean Pericles person Philoctetes phronesis Plato pleonexia polis political practical rationality practical reasoning practical syllogism premises presupposed principles prohairesis question rational justification recognize relationship requires respect rules of justice Scotland Scottish sions social order Socrates someone Sophocles specific Stair standards standpoint syllogism synderesis telos theology theory Thrasymachus Thucydides thumos tical tion tradition of enquiry Treatise truth understanding understood universal virtue