Patriarchal Religion, Sexuality, and Gender: A Critique of New Natural Law

Front Cover
Cambridge University Press, Dec 6, 2007 - Law
Legal theorists are familiar with John Finnis's book Natural Law and Natural Rights, but usually overlook his interventions in US constitutional debates and his membership of a group of conservative Catholic thinkers, the 'new natural lawyers', led by theologian Germain Grisez. In fact, Finnis has repeatedly advocated conservative positions concerning lesbian and gay rights, contraception and abortion, and his substantive moral theory (as he himself acknowledges) derives from Grisez. Bamforth and Richards provide a detailed explanation of the work of the new natural lawyers within and outside the Catholic Church - the first truly comprehensive explanation available to legal theorists - and criticize Grisez's and Finnis's arguments concerning sexuality and gender. New natural law is, they argue, a theology rather than a secular theory, and one which is unappealing in a modern constitutional democracy. This book will be of interest to legal and political theorists, ethicists, theologians and scholars of religious history.
 

What people are saying - Write a review

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Excellent overview and analysis of the so-called 'basic goods theory' or New Natural Law theory of ethics that has, despite its pretensions, manufactured nothing productive in ethics other than an almost impenetrably abstruse web of sophistry and illusion. Bamforth and Richards slice through this jibberish with lucid critical reasoning, providing a refreshing break from the likes of Robert P. George and other long-winded defenders of this outdated and pre-modern concept of ethics. This book is long over-due! A very important contribution to the debate.  

Contents

1 New Natural Law in Context
1
2 Criteria for Evaluating New Natural Law
17
3 The Architecture and Reach of New Natural Law
56
Is New Natural Law Secular?
93
New Natural Law and Thomas Aquinas
151
Whats Wrong with Homophobia and Sexism?
190
New Natural Law Sexism and Homophobia
228
8 Moral Absolutes and the Possible Fundamentalism of New Natural Law
279
9 New Natural Law and Patriarchal Religion
304
10 Concluding Observations and Christian Alternatives to New Natural Law
334
Bibliography
371
Index
393
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

Bibliographic information