The Argumentative Indian: Writings on Indian History, Culture and Identity

Front Cover
Macmillan, Oct 12, 2005 - History - 409 pages
A Nobel Laureate offers a dazzling new book about his native country
India is a country with many distinct traditions, widely divergent customs, vastly different convictions, and a veritable feast of viewpoints. In The Argumentative Indian, Amartya Sen draws on a lifetime study of his country’s history and culture to suggest the ways we must understand India today in the light of its rich, long argumentative tradition.
The millenia-old texts and interpretations of Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, Muslim, agnostic, and atheistic Indian thought demonstrate, Sen reminds us, ancient and well-respected rules for conducting debates and disputations, and for appreciating not only the richness of India’s diversity but its need for toleration.
Though Westerners have often perceived India as a place of endless spirituality and unreasoning mysticism, he underlines its long tradition of skepticism and reasoning, not to mention its secular contributions to mathematics, astronomy, linguistics, medicine, and political economy.
Sen discusses many aspects of India’s rich intellectual and political heritage, including philosophies of governance from Kautilya’s and Ashoka’s in the fourth and third centuries BCE to Akbar’s in the 1590s; the history and continuing relevance of India’s relations with China more than a millennium ago; its old and well-organized calendars; the films of Satyajit Ray and the debates between Gandhi and the visionary poet Tagore about India's past, present, and future.
The success of India’s democracy and defense of its secular politics depend, Sen argues, on understanding and using this rich argumentative tradition. It is also essential to removing the inequalities (whether of caste, gender, class, or community) that mar Indian life, to stabilizing the now precarious conditions of a nuclear-armed subcontinent, and to correcting what Sen calls the politics of deprivation. His invaluable book concludes with his meditations on pluralism, on dialogue and dialectics in the pursuit of social justice, and on the nature of the Indian identity.
 

What people are saying - Write a review

User ratings

5 stars
1
4 stars
3
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 star
3

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - danoomistmatiste - LibraryThing

Halfway thru this book and here are some thoughts. Hard to put a single description on this one, but here is a weak attempt. A very interesting collage of articles running the gamut and trying to ... Read full review

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - prasenjeet - LibraryThing

I bought this book because I was curious what Amartya Sen (a noted economist had to say) on India's history and philosophical traditions. Apart from a few good points he makes about India's ... Read full review

Contents

Page 25
3
Page 26
4
Page 27
5
Page 28
6
Page 29
7
Page 30
8
Page 31
9
Page 32
10
Page 229
207
Page 230
208
Page 231
209
Page 232
210
Page 233
211
Page 234
212
Page 235
213
Page 236
214

Page 33
11
Page 34
12
Page 35
13
Page 36
14
Page 37
15
Page 38
16
Page 39
17
Page 40
18
Page 41
19
Page 42
20
Page 43
21
Page 44
22
Page 45
23
Page 46
24
Page 47
25
Page 48
26
Page 49
27
Page 50
28
Page 51
29
Page 52
30
Page 53
31
Page 54
32
Page 55
33
Page 56
34
Page 57
35
Page 58
36
Page 59
37
Page 60
38
Page 61
39
Page 62
40
Page 63
41
Page 64
42
Page 65
43
Page 66
44
Page 67
45
Page 68
46
Page 69
47
Page 70
48
Page 71
49
Page 72
50
Page 73
51
Page 74
52
Page 75
53
Page 76
54
Page 77
55
Page 78
56
Page 79
57
Page 80
58
Page 81
59
Page 82
60
Page 83
61
Page 84
62
Page 85
63
Page 86
64
Page 87
65
Page 88
66
Page 89
67
Page 90
68
Page 91
69
Page 92
70
Page 93
71
Page 94
72
Page 95
73
Page 96
74
Page 97
75
Page 98
76
Page 99
77
Page 100
78
Page 101
79
Page 102
80
Page 103
81
Page 104
82
Page 105
83
Page 106
84
Page 107
85
Page 108
86
Page 109
87
Page 110
88
Page 111
89
Page 112
90
Page 113
91
Page 114
92
Page 115
93
Page 116
94
Page 117
95
Page 118
96
Page 119
97
Page 120
98
Page 121
99
Page 122
100
Page 123
101
Page 124
102
Page 125
103
Page 126
104
Page 127
105
Page 128
106
Page 129
107
Page 130
108
Page 131
109
Page 132
110
Page 133
111
Page 134
112
Page 135
113
Page 136
114
Page 137
115
Page 138
116
Page 139
117
Page 140
118
Page 141
119
Page 142
120
Page 143
121
Page 144
122
Page 145
123
Page 146
124
Page 147
125
Page 148
126
Page 149
127
Page 150
128
Page 151
129
Page 152
130
Page 153
131
Page 154
132
Page 155
133
Page 156
134
Page 157
135
Page 158
136
Page 159
137
Page 160
138
Page 161
139
Page 162
140
Page 163
141
Page 164
142
Page 165
143
Page 166
144
Page 167
145
Page 168
146
Page 169
147
Page 170
148
Page 171
149
Page 172
150
Page 173
151
Page 174
152
Page 175
153
Page 176
154
Page 177
155
Page 178
156
Page 179
157
Page 180
158
Page 181
159
Page 182
160
Page 183
161
Page 184
162
Page 185
163
Page 186
164
Page 187
165
Page 188
166
Page 189
167
Page 190
168
Page 191
169
Page 192
170
Page 193
171
Page 194
172
Page 195
173
Page 196
174
Page 197
175
Page 198
176
Page 199
177
Page 200
178
Page 201
179
Page 202
180
Page 203
181
Page 204
182
Page 205
183
Page 206
184
Page 207
185
Page 208
186
Page 209
187
Page 210
188
Page 211
189
Page 212
190
Page 213
191
Page 214
192
Page 215
193
Page 216
194
Page 217
195
Page 218
196
Page 219
197
Page 220
198
Page 221
199
Page 222
200
Page 223
201
Page 224
202
Page 225
203
Page 226
204
Page 227
205
Page 228
206
Page 237
215
Page 238
216
Page 239
217
Page 240
218
Page 241
219
Page 242
220
Page 243
221
Page 244
222
Page 245
223
Page 246
224
Page 247
225
Page 248
226
Page 249
227
Page 250
228
Page 251
229
Page 252
230
Page 253
231
Page 254
232
Page 255
233
Page 256
234
Page 257
235
Page 258
236
Page 259
237
Page 260
238
Page 261
239
Page 262
240
Page 263
241
Page 264
242
Page 265
243
Page 266
244
Page 267
245
Page 268
246
Page 269
247
Page 270
248
Page 271
249
Page 272
250
Page 273
251
Page 274
252
Page 275
253
Page 276
254
Page 277
255
Page 278
256
Page 279
257
Page 280
258
Page 281
259
Page 282
260
Page 283
261
Page 284
262
Page 285
263
Page 286
264
Page 287
265
Page 288
266
Page 289
267
Page 290
268
Page 291
269
Page 292
270
Page 293
271
Page 294
272
Page 295
273
Page 296
274
Page 297
275
Page 298
276
Page 299
277
Page 300
278
Page 301
279
Page 302
280
Page 303
281
Page 304
282
Page 305
283
Page 306
284
Page 307
285
Page 308
286
Page 309
287
Page 310
288
Page 311
289
Page 312
290
Page 313
291
Page 314
292
Page 315
293
Page 316
294
Page 317
295
Page 318
296
Page 319
297
Page 320
298
Page 321
299
Page 322
300
Page 323
301
Page 324
302
Page 325
303
Page 326
304
Page 327
305
Page 328
306
Page 329
307
Page 330
308
Page 331
309
Page 332
310
Page 333
311
Page 334
312
Page 335
313
Page 336
314
Page 337
315
Page 338
316
Page 339
317
Page 340
318
Page 341
319
Page 342
320
Page 343
321
Page 344
322
Page 345
323
Page 346
324
Page 347
325
Page 348
326
Page 349
327
Page 350
328
Page 351
329
Page 352
330
Page 353
331
Page 354
332
Page 355
333
Page 356
334
Page 357
335
Page 358
336
Page 359
337
Page 360
338
Page 361
339
Page 362
340
Page 363
341
Page 364
342
Page 365
343
Page 366
344
Page 367
345
Page 368
346
Page 369
347
Page 370
348
Page 371
349
Page 372
350
Page 373
351
Page 374
352
Page 375
353
Page 376
354
Page 377
355
Page 378
356
Page 379
357
Page 380
358
Page 381
359
Page 382
360
Page 383
361
Page 384
362
Page 385
363
Page 386
364
Page 387
365
Page 388
366
Page 389
367
Page 390
368
Page 391
369
Page 392
370
Page 393
371
Page 394
372
Page 395
373
Page 396
374
Page 397
375
Page 398
376
Page 399
377
Page 400
378
Page 401
379
Page 402
380
Page 403
381
Page 404
382
Page 405
383
Page 406
384
Page 407
385
Page 408
386
Page 409
387
Page 410
388
Page 411
389
Page 412
390
Page 413
391
Page 414
392
Page 415
393
Page 416
394
Page 417
395
Page 418
396
Page 419
397
Page 420
398
Page 421
399
Page 422
400
Page 423
401
Page 424
402
Page 425
403
Page 426
404
Page 427
405
Page 428
406
Page 429
407
Page 430
408
Page 431
409
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2005)

Amartya Sen is Lamont University Professor at Harvard. He won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1998 and was Master of Trinity College, Cambridge, 1998–2004. His most recent books are Development as Freedom (Knopf, 1999) and Rationality and Freedom (Harvard University Press, 2002). His books have been translated into thirty languages.

Bibliographic information