The Testing Trap: How State Writing Assessments Control Learning

Front Cover
Teachers College Press, 2002 - Education - 224 pages
2 Reviews
Hardly a day goes by in America without talk of testing students to higher standards as a means to improve our education system. In The Testing Trap, George Hillocks puts this logic to the test.

Through interviews with over three hundred teachers and administrators, Hillocks examines whether state writing tests in Illinois, Kentucky, Oregon, New York, and Texas do what they are supposed to do: Improve education. Ultimately, Hillocks argues that the majority of existing tests actually have a harmful effect on the way students are taught to write.

In The Testing Trap, Hillocks demonstrates how the structure of assessment is actually responsible for the low level of thinking encouraged and reinforced in American classrooms. It is his contention that although politicians call for excellence, the tests that they create, and the formulaic writing they accept as passing, actually point to mediocrity as their true aim. In this way, political objectives are easily achieved but our children suffer the consequences.

In addition to providing analyses of assessments that do not encourage good writing, The Testing Trap contrasts them to those that do. Concluding with practical procedures for examining and evaluating writing assessments, this book is a provocative and essential read for administrators, teachers, policymakers, parents, and all who care about the education of our children.


What people are saying - Write a review

Review: The Testing Trap: How State Writing Assessments Control Learning

User Review  - Christine Fay - Goodreads

Okay, so this book was for my Assessment class at Bridgewater State, but it explains why I haven't been reading as much, doesn't it? This author set about interviewing 300 teachers across 5 states ... Read full review

Review: The Testing Trap: How State Writing Assessments Control Learning

User Review  - RRVWP - Goodreads

Hillocks deftly challenges state testing by looking at particular states and the assessments they use. Read full review


CHAPTER 1 The Politics of Mandatory Assessment
CHAPTER 2 The Study of State Writing Assessments
CHAPTER 3 Foundations of Testing
CHAPTER 4 A Test Is Not a Test
CHAPTER 5 High Stakes and Mediocrity in Texas
The Case of Texas
The Case of Illinois
CHAPTER 8 Schools Teachers and the Illinois Assessment
The Case of New York
CHAPTER 10 Portfolio Assessment in Kentucky and Oregon
Oregon and Kentucky
CHAPTER 12 Testing Thinking and Needed Change
About the Author

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

References to this book

All Book Search results »

Bibliographic information