Race, Liberalism, and EconomicsDavid Colander, Robert E. Prasch, Falguni A. Sheth Noneconomists often think that economists' approach to race is almost exclusively one of laissez-faire. Racism, Liberalism, and Economics argues that economists' ideas are more complicated. The book considers economists' support of markets in relation to the challenge of race and race relations and argues that their support of laissez-faire has traditionally been based upon a broader philosophical foundation of liberalism and history: what markets have and have not achieved in the past, and how that past relates to the future. The book discusses the concepts of liberalism and racism, the history and use of these terms, and how that history relates to policy issues. It argues that liberalism is consistent with a wide variety of policies and that the broader philosophical issues are central in choosing policies. The contributors show how the evolution of racist ideas has been a subtle process that is woven into larger movements in the development of scientific thought; economic thinking is embedded in a larger social milieu. Previous discussions of policies toward race have been constrained by that social milieu, and, since World War II, have largely focused on ending legislated and state-sanctioned discrimination. In the past decade, the broader policy debate has moved on to questions about the existence and relative importance of intangible sources of inequality, including market structure, information asymmetries, cumulative processes, and cultural and/or social capital. This book is a product of, and a contribution to, this modern discussion. It is uniquely transdisciplinary, with contributions by and discussions among economists, philosophers, anthropologists, and literature scholars. The volume first examines the early history of work on race by economists and social scientists more generally. It continues by surveying American economists on race and featuring contributions that embody more modern approaches to race within economics. Finally it explores several important policy issues that follow from the discussion. ". . . adds new insights that contribute significantly to the debate on racial economic inequality in the U.S. The differing opinions of the contributors provide the broad perspective needed to examine this extremely complex issue." --James Peoples, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee "There is an immense economic literature on racial discrimination, employing a variety of models and decomposition methods. This volume makes a unique contribution by focusing on the philosophical assumptions at the root of this analysis and by presenting many sides of the very vigorous debate surrounding these controversial issues." --Thomas Maloney, University of Utah "By focusing upon the progress of analytical technique, historians of economic thought have grossly neglected the symbiotic relation of economics to public policy and ideology. This collection of essays offers a most welcome breach of disciplinary apartheid. Seizing upon recent research in the almost forgotten writings about race of Classical economists and their contemporaries, it relates nineteenth-century ideas to current debates about economic discrimination and other manifestations of racism. As the writing is both learned and lively, the book should appeal both to the generally educated reader and to teachers of courses in multiculturalism." --Melvin Reder, Isidore Brown and Gladys J. Brown Professor Emeritus of Urban and Labor Economics, University of Chicago |
Contents
| 12 | |
Brendan OFlaherty and Jill S Shapiro 21 | 21 |
Classical Economics | 56 |
Contextualizing David Levys How the Dismal Science | 85 |
John Stuart Mill on Race Liberty and Markets | 100 |
How Economics Succumbed | 123 |
One Hundred Years of American Economists on Race | 145 |
Racial Discrimination in the Labor Market | 182 |
Liberty and Equality and Diversity? Thoughts | 205 |
Other editions - View all
Race, Liberalism, and Economics David Colander,Robert E. Prasch,Falguni A. Sheth Limited preview - 2004 |
Race, Liberalism, and Economics David Colander,Robert E. Prasch,Falguni A. Sheth Limited preview - 2006 |
Common terms and phrases
AFQT scores African American analysis anthropology apes approach argue argument Becker believe black workers Blumenbach capitalism Carlyle Carlyle's chap chapter Chicago classical economics classical liberal competitive critics culture Darity Darwin debate discrimination dismal science DuBois economists emancipation employers Enlightenment equal eugenics European evidence example free markets Gary Becker Hispanic History of Economic human nature ideas income individuals inferior institutions Irish John John Stuart Mill Journal of Economic justice labor market laws Levy and Peart Levy's liberty Loury Mill Mill's modern liberals moral Negro Question neoclassical nineteenth century nomic outcomes paternalism paternalistic percent persons perspective philosophical Political Economy polygenists poor position problem race racial inequality racial profiling racism reason recreational drugs reform role Ruskin scientists skills slavery slaves social society Sowell species theory Thomas Carlyle tion University Press Victorian W. E. B. DuBois wages wealth women York