What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
Abolitionists addressed Aldermen to grant Alton side Applause and hisses arms assert Attorney-General audience Austin back my words Boston broken into voice chairman Channing headed citizens civil authority conflict of laws declared that Lovejoy eloquence excitement EYE WITNESSES Faneuil Hall fathers fell Fellow-citizens fool dieth FREEDOM SPEECH gallery glorious headed a petition heard the gentleman herewith check Illinois indignation Jonathan Phillips LETTERS FROM EYE liberty listened Lovejoy died Lovejoy was presumptuous Mayor and Aldermen meeting in Faneuil memory Missouri mob at Alton MURDER OF LOVEJOY murderers of Alton OK LOVEJOY orderly mob Otis and Hancock patriots Phillips Hall Association pictured lips place the murderers presumptuous and imprudent Quincy and Adams rebuke the recreant recreant American resolutions right of self-defence rioters sanction side with Otis slaves SPEECH OF WENDELL sympathy take back thought those pictured threw the tea voice never voice to rebuke Wendell Phillips Hall
Page iii - Sir, when I heard the gentleman lay down principles which place the murderers of Alton side by side with Otis and Hancock, with Quincy and Adams, I thought those pictured lips [pointing to the portraits in the Hall] would have broken into voice to rebuke the recreant American, — the slanderer of the dead.
Page 7 - How would the intimation have been received, that Warren and his associates should have waited a better time? But if success be indeed the only criterion of prudence, Respice finem — wait till the end. Presumptuous to assert the freedom of the press on American ground ! Is the assertion of such freedom before the age ? So much before the age as to leave one no right to make it because it displeases the community? Who invents this libel on his country? It is this very thing which entitles Lovejoy...
Page 8 - They saw that of which we cannot judge, the necessity of resistance. Insulted law called for it. Public opinion, fast hastening on the downward course, must be arrested. Does not the event show they judged rightly ? Absorbed in a thousand trifles, how has the nation all at once come to a stand ? Men begin, as in 1776 and 1640, to discuss principles, to weigh characters, to find out where they are. Haply we may awake before we are borne over the precipice. I am glad, Sir, to see this crowded house....
Page 2 - I did not come here to take any part in this discussion, nor do I intend to ; but I do entreat you, fellow citizens, by everything you hold sacred, — I conjure you by every association connected with this Hall, consecrated by our fathers to freedom of discussion,— that you listen to every man who addresses you in a decorous mantier.
Page vi - Fellow-citizens, is this Faneuil Hall doctrine ? [" No, no."] The mob at Alton were met to wrest from a citizen his just rights, — met to resist the laws. We have been told that our fathers did the same ; and the glorious mantle of Revolutionary precedent has been thrown over the mobs of our day. To make out their title to such defence, the gentleman says that the British Parliament had a right to tax these Colonies. It is manifest that, without this, his parallel falls to the ground ; for Lovejoy...
Page 2 - State from another be an imaginary one or ocean-wide, the moment you cross it, the State you leave is blotted out of existence, so far as you are concerned. The Czar might as well claim to control the deliberations of Faneuil Hall, as the laws of Missouri demand reverence, or the shadow of obedience, from an inhabitant of Illinois.
Page 6 - The gentleman says Lovejoy was presumptuous and imprudent — he " died as the fool dieth." And a reverend clergyman of the city tells us that no citizen has a right to publish opinions disagreeable to the community!' If any mob follows such publication, on him rests its guilt. He must wait, forsooth, till the people come up to it and agree with him ! This libel on liberty goes on to say that the want of right to speak as we think is an evil inseparable from republican institutions ! If this be so,...
Page v - Hallett, were unanimously adopted, and measures taken to secure a much larger number of names to the petition. This call the Mayor and Aldermen obeyed. The meeting was held on the 8th of December, and organized, with the Hon. Jonathan Phillips for Chairman. Dr. Channing made a brief and eloquent address. Resolutions, drawn by him, were then read and offered by Mr.
Page 7 - One word, gentlemen. As much as thought is better than money, so much is the cause in which Lovejoy died nobler than a mere question of taxes. James Otis thundered in this hall when the king did but touch his pocket. Imagine, if you can, his indignant eloquence had England offered to put a gag upon his lips.
Page 5 - damn with faint praise," or load with obloquy, the memory of this man, who shed his blood in defence of life, liberty, property, and the freedom of the press! Throughout that terrible night I find nothing to regret but this, that within the limits of our country, civil authority should have been so prostrated as to oblige a citizen to arm in his own defence, and to arm in vain. The gentleman says Lovejoy was presumptuous and imprudent, —he