Results 1-9 of 9

Unlike Harry Potter

User Review  - Lottman - Borders

It is stipulated that the book is similar to Hary Potter, but it is not. It perhaps may be similiar to Narnia more so in a very broad spectrum. The book is dark only in that the characters have ... Read full review

Interesting but not really

User Review  - LilyPB - Borders

I have mixed feelings about this book. I read the book upon someone’s suggestion that referred to it as the “adult version of Harry Potter meets Narnia”. Well, the book definitely portrays the mundane ... Read full review

Mediocre at Best

User Review  - LoverOfClassics - Borders

I truly wanted to like this book. In the beginning, I became excited at the idea of this book. Several chapters in, I was hooked. Then I started to notice how much was stolen from other literature ... Read full review

Too bad Harry Potter came before this one

User Review  - numbnerve - Borders

Had Harry Potter not invaded the world, this novel may have stood alone; and to make it even more codependent, Grossman continually gives nods to JK Rowling's Potter (& a couple jabs) While reading ... Read full review

Different, but maybe not in a good way

User Review  - fuzzyivo - Borders

This was a bit darker than I expected it to be. That didn't bother me so much as the fixation on a Narnian look-alike book the kids are into. It's also a bit heavy on the figuring out who I am teenage agnst thing. Not a bad book, just be prepared for different and slightly wierd. Read full review

You have to at least try it, who knows

User Review  - RayneDarkShadow - Borders

I have heard both the good and the bad about this book and have just read it. After doing so all I can say is that it is an experience that you have to try for yourself in order to know if you like it ... Read full review

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

An interesting take on the youngster who learns of a fantasy realm genre. It is a good read, but much of the character interaction seems forced into a middle-school or high-school clique mold. There is a lot of superfluous chatter that doesn't make the story any more or less interesting, but leaves a lot of virtual question marks for the author throughout the book. I would put The Magicians in the same class as the novel Wicked. 

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

A lonely teenage boy is picked from obscurity and begins to attend a magical school in Lev Grossman’s 2009 bestseller, The Magicians. Sounds familiar, right? Comparisons to the Harry Potter series may spring to mind, but this is no Hogwarts.
Quentin Coldwater, high school genius, is a depressed young man who exists in our world while desiring to live in Fillory, a fictional, Narnia-type world that he reads about in books. Quentin is much more Holden Caulfield than Harry Potter when he finds himself wandering through a portal that leads him to the entrance of Brakebills, a college dedicated to teaching magic. Knowing magic is real and dedicating himself to its study seems to be the answer to Quentin’s prayers—he’s no longer alone in the world.
The Magicians is two books in one. The first focuses on Quentin’s education and his navigation of the magical world that exists all around us. The years at Brakebills are the most charming part of the story. Readers will be enchanted by the magical college and the contemporary fantasy that Grossman weaves.
Teachers we meet, but never really get to know, help students learn their spells. Hints are dropped about their colorful backgrounds and achievements, but readers are left wondering about the staff’s origins. Meanwhile, a trip to Brakebills South gives a peek into another magic school—a much darker version, where students are pushed beyond measure by a sadist teacher, whom we yearn to know more about.
During his school years Quentin makes a group of friends (or at least a circle of other misanthropes like himself), and together they drink, smoke, cook fantastic meals, and have sex while defining themselves as magicians. Still, character development is a weaker part of the story. Very few layers are revealed, and characters become one dimensional: the punk, the gay guy, the fat kid, the innocent nerd, and the party girl. Quentin himself is always depressed, but he never knows why. He and friends, however, are not afraid to ask the questions that many fantasy readers have always wondered: when you have absolute power, what’s left? When you can do whatever you want, how should you proceed in life?
The second part of the story contributes some answers to their questions. After months of acting like spoiled rich kids, Quentin and his friends essentially hit bottom. With no direction, their post-graduation world becomes one big drug-filled party. They need something to save the group of lost souls from themselves, and it comes in the form of a quest. The graduates are given the opportunity to travel into another world—the world of Quentin’s obsession, Fillory. As they enter this new world, the novel begins to have much more traditional fantasy elements, though some readers may consider this a caricature of Narnia.
Grossman creates a very deep world in The Magicians, but he only skims the surface. The concept of flawed people dealing with power is intriguing after the usual over-the-top heroes of fantasy novels, but you have to care about characters to want to keep reading a series. The characters remain fairly unlikeable throughout the book, and there may be too many similarities to other fantasy series for some readers.
The Magicians is not for every fantasy fan, as it alternates frustrating reality with flawed dreams, but if you’re a fan of coming-of-age stories and would like to take a peek into the magical worlds around us, this may be a book you’ll love.
 

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

This is a fun enough book about a disenchanted teenager going to magic college. It really is like Harry Potter with higher bit of verisimilitude and teen angst when the action is taking place in non-magical settings.
It was an easy, enjoyable read, but I did not find it compelling or captivating like, say, I did the Narnia books in my youth.
 


User ratings

5 stars
21
4 stars
13
3 stars
10
2 stars
5
1 star
8

5 stars - 11
3 stars - 9
1 star - 6


Borders - 30
Kirkus - 1