Legal Indeterminacy and Constitutional Interpretation
The main purpose of this book is to offer a logical analysis of legal propositions, especially of constitutional propositions. This analysis shows the relationship between truth-conditions of legal propositions and the problem of indeterminacy. Where the law is indeterminate, legal propositions lack truth-values. The background of this approach is the philosophical debate between realism and antirealism. The book deals with the notions of legal norms and legal systems and provides an analysis of the notion of legal indeterminacy and its relation to gaps, contradictions and the vagueness of legal concepts. It shows also that the simple model of a legal system is not sufficient to account for the complexity of legal propositions referring to legal systems of some degree of maturity. Several notions from legal dynamics are presented in order to bring to light the importance of concepts like applicability or hierarchy for the determination of the truth-value of a legal proposition. Thus the primacy of constitution becomes a central idea in the theoretical reconstruction of most contemporary legal systems; a conceptual explanation of this idea is presented and some conclusions from that explanation are drawn. Finally, a particular conception of constitutional interpretation is proposed. Special attention is paid to the relationship between interpretation and legal indeterminacy and, more specifically, to the problem of the discretion enjoyed by the organs entrusted with applying the constitution and also to the several theses that have been discussed controversially in the context of constitutional interpretation, such as the relevance of the intentions for the interpretation of the constitution and for the justification of judicial review.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
The Theory of Force and Prescriptions
ALogical Analysis of Legal Propositions
The Law Is Silent
The Applicability of Legal Norms
Valid But Inapplicable Norms
The Thesis of Constitutional Accessibility
The Noble Dream
Other editions - View all
according accordingto Alchourrón/Bulygin alegal andthe applicable argument assertion behaviour belong belongto bivalence bythe canbe conception conclusion constitutional constitutionally corresponding courts Critical Legal Studies definition deontic deontic logic determine dformula disjunction disjunction introduction distinguish doesnot Dworkin formula Girona heap implies inconsistent indeterminacy intentions internal realism interpretation inthe irrelevant isan isnot isthe itis Iwill Kelsen language legal norms legal order legal propositions legal realism legal statements legal system legal thesis logical consequence meaning metaphysical realism modus ponens moral moral realism negation norm N normative consequences normative system normformulations notion notionof oflegal propositions ofnorms ofthe onthe paradoxical permitted philosophical possible precisely predicate presupposes prohibited properties question reasons relevant relevant logical semantic sense sentence sequence skepticism socalled sorites Strawson supervenience thatis thatthe thelaw thelegal theory theoryof thereis tothe truth truthconditions truthvalue University of Girona vagueness valid wecan withthe Wittgenstein