The Metaphysics of Apes: Negotiating the Animal-Human Boundary

Front Cover
Cambridge University Press, Mar 14, 2005 - Science - 227 pages
1 Review
The Metaphysics of Apes traces the discovery and interpretation of the human-like great apes and the ape-like earliest ancestors of present-day humans. It shows how, from the days of Linnaeus to recent research, the sacred and taboo-ridden animal-human boundary was time and again challenged and adjusted. The unique dignity of humans is centrally on the minds of taxonomists, ethnologists, primatologists, and archaeologists, guiding their research considerably and a basic presupposition was that humans are not entirely part of nature but rather, transcend nature. This book thus is the first to offer an anthropological analysis of these anthropological disciplines in terms of their own cultural taboos and philosophical preconceptions.
 

What people are saying - Write a review

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Raymond Corbey's The Metaphysics of Apes deserves to become a classic for its intellectual acuity and its disciplinary breadth. This is a profoundly significant anthropological disquisition in that it asks questions so central to questions of the human condition, and its purported uniqueness. Corbey provides a comprehensive review of the various ways in which ideas about apes have implicitly and explicitly contributed to a variety of Euro-American anthropological discourses. As an indication, these include; the formative understandings and misunderstandings deriving from the earliest dissections of 'orang-outang' bodies, in which we learn how the anatomical work of Tulp and Tyson gave rise to profound metaphysical musings; the tensions between taxonomy and Christian theology; the apishness or otherwise of our hominid ancestors as discovered and theoretically reconstructed by paleoanthropologists and archaeoplogists; and the dispute between sociobiologists and cultural anthropologists, with their divergent pre-theoretical commitments. Corbey's text is both intelligible and engaging, and seductive for its historical and epistemological approach to the question of the human in philosophy, biology, and anthropology. Corbey gives us cause to recall not just the fluid boundary between humans and (other) primates, but also the similarly shared motivations of disparate disciplines. This book shall definitely feature strongly in the bibliographies for my anthropological teaching. 

Contents

Ambiguous Apes
5
Crafting the Primate Order
36
Up from the Ape
60
Homos Humanness
92
Symbolic Man in Ethnology
121
Pan Sapiens?
145
Beyond Dualism
178
Bibliography
203
Index
225
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2005)

Raymond Corbey is Professor of Epistemology and Anthropology at Leiden University and Lecturer in philosophy at Tilburg University, both in the Netherlands. He has published extensively on the history of philosophical, scientific, and colloquial views of humans, animals, evolution, culture and cultural others, as well as on the history and epistemology of anthropology and the formation of ethnographic museums and collections. He is co-director of the research program Thoughtful Hunters? Neanderthal Behavioural and Cognitive Socioecology. He is the co-editor with Wil Roebroeks of Studying Human Animals: Disciplinary History and Epistemology (2001).

Bibliographic information