The Burden of Sympathy: How Families Cope with Mental Illness
What are the limits of sympathy in dealing with another person's troubles? Where do we draw the line between caring for a loved one, and being swallowed up emotionally by the obligation to do so? Quite simply, what do we owe each other? In this vivid and thoughtful study, David Karp chronicles the experiences of the family members of the mentally ill, and how they draw "boundaries of sympathy" to avoid being engulfed by the day-to-day suffering of a loved one.
Working from sixty extensive interviews, the author reveals striking similarities in the experiences of caregivers: the feelings of shame, fear, guilt and powerlessness in the face of a socially stigmatized illness; the frustration of navigating the complex network of bureaucracies that govern the mental health system; and most of all, the difficulty negotiating an "appropriate" level of involvement with the mentally ill loved one while maintaining enough distance for personal health. Throughout the narratives, Karp sensitively explores the overarching question of how people strike an equilibrium between reason and emotion, between head and heart, when caring for a catastrophically ill person. The Burden of Sympathy concludes with a critical look at what it means to be a moral and caring person at the turn of the century in America, when powerful cultural messages spell out two contradictory imperatives: pursue personal fulfillment at any cost and care for the family at any cost.
An insightful, deeply caring look at mental illness and at the larger picture of contemporary values, The Burden of Sympathy is required reading for caregivers of all kinds, and for anyone seeking broader understanding of human responsibility in the postmodern world.
What people are saying - Write a review
Review: The Burden of SympathyUser Review - Linda Kuramoto - Goodreads
Based upon three years of interviewing families affected by mental illness, Karp was able to identify unique challenges associated with caring for a child, sibling, spouse and parent. I wish that I ... Read full review
Other editions - View all
age thirty-five American anger Angie anomie become behaviors Bell Curve Boston College boundaries brother C. B. MacPherson caring cause chapter characteri2ed child commitment communitarian conversation crisis cultural cure daughter deal depression described diagnosis doctors emotionally emotions eventually experience family caregivers father feel felt Gail Georg Simmel going hate hope hospital hospitali2ed human husband hypomania ill family member individuals interviewed involuntary commitment Jason Jeff kind Leslie lives manic-depression mean mental health system mentally ill person Mike moral mother Nancy never obligation Organi2ation pain parents patients PHYSICAL THERAPIST postmodern Press problem Prozac psychiatrists question realize relationship responsibility role role-taking romantic love schi2ophrenia sense sibling sick sister social order society Sociology Sociology of Emotions someone sort spouse stories suicide sympathy Talcott Parsons talk tell theories THERAPIST things Thomas Hobbes tion told treatment trying understand women York