User Review - Flag as inappropriate
There are some really important ideas in this book, and some oversimplifications. I found myself very frustrated at times with the reduction of music to the playing of notes, the unconscious bias to a western conception of musical learning, or the reduction of understanding to the operations of the brain, but these are simply paradigm problems - what he says is not wrong it just doesn't show the whole picture. On the other hand his perspective on the evolutionary position of musicality is very interesting and thought-provoking. By presenting his broad literature review drawing on his own formidable research in the context of his personal experience as a musical learner Marcus has done something quite extraordinary here, and for all its flaws this is a fascinating book and invaluable to anyone who is serious about understanding musicality.