Reviews

User reviews

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Great
Great!!

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

I love this book!! It is so awsome!!
wow! this book is so awsome! -Olivia, age

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

One word: Wow.
Ya gotta admit, Erin Hunter is the best. The story is so similarly written the whole way through, you wouldn't know the author is actually four different people. The whole Sandstorm
V Spottedleaf thing really makes ya pull a face to yourself.
I always knew SkyClan would make a dramatic entrance somewhere, but I never thought in this way. Incredible!
It's definitely good to see all our favourite characters again, and you have to love how Firestar's deputy is his best friend. It's good to see Smudge making a return as well. Love that little guy!
>^-^<
My favourite part has to be when Firestar loses Sandstorm in a huge wave in the flood; Tons of drama in there. It's all 'Must do this' 'Must do that' 'StarClan help me' 'Why, Spottedleaf?'.
And it's not all hunky-dorey. You must remember that Sandstorm's opinion of Firestar sort of changes a lot.
The worst part, although I'd hate to say there IS a worst part, is probably how Firestar has so much responsibility of being leader and he can't sleep in the warriors' den and share tongues like old times. Poor kitty.
I give it 5 stars! This bigger-than-usual book will keep me busy for a while!
 

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Review
For a while, I read in confusion at the prospect of sandstorm being blind to Firestars first love of spotted leaf. This book answered that while delivering a solid story. If you liked Midnight and Moonrise you will enjoy this book. 8.5 out of 10. Some parts were a little slow.

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

awesome plain aesome

Captivating

User Review  - Graystripe - Borders

This book is very good. I liked it so much, I named my Turkish Angora after the cat Hattie, in the book. I would recommend it to anyone. Read full review

User ratings

5 stars
15
4 stars
2
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 star
0

All reviews - 11
3 stars - 0
2 stars - 0
1 star - 0

All reviews - 11
Editorial reviews - 0

All reviews - 11