The sodomy cases: Bowers v. Hardwick and Lawrence v. TexasFor America's gay community, the question of rights is often reduced to the issue of privacy. Until very recently, even though this right has been upheld by the Supreme Court in landmark cases relating to contraception and abortion, the issue of "nonprocreational sex" continued to trigger a double standard for gay men. Now David Richards, a leading legal scholar who is himself gay, shows how two other landmark cases nearly twenty years apart shed light on America's evolving views of privacy. The Supreme Court's decision in Bowers v. Hardwick (1986) stemmed from a 1982 gay-sex arrest in an Atlanta home under a Georgia law that criminalized sodomy--a case not originally prosecuted, but then pursued in court to challenge the statute's constitutionality. Lawrence v. Texas (2003) followed a similar arrest in 1998 in Houston, where Texas law also criminalized sodomy--but only when practiced by members of the same sex. Richards views these cases as the nadir and apogee of the gay community's efforts to fight discrimination through the courts. In Bowers, the Supreme Court ruled that there was no constitutional protection for sodomy and that states could outlaw those practices. But in Lawrence, the Court overturned the Texas law--and the Bowers decision as well--because it denied due process protection to consenting adults whose sexual practices were conducted in private. Justice Kennedy's majority opinion reaffirmed a constitutionally protected right to privacy that prevented the government from regulating intimate behavior. Tracing the Court's deliberations, Richards shows how Lawrence unambiguously establishes that the right to a private life is an innately human right and that ourconstitutional right to privacy rests on the moral bedrock of equal protection. He shifts gracefully from the law to literature, and from the Courts to the wider culture, to offer a brilliant analysis of the relevant arguments, going beneath their surface to link them to the emotional and moral foundations of the controversies raging around these decisions. Both of these cases show a Supreme Court ready to take seriously the idea that homosexuals have human rights--and that these rights are the basis of judicially enforceable constitutional rights. In describing these challenges to public prejudice, Richards's book offers students and general readers new insight into the practice and theory of constitutional law. |
From inside the book
22 pages matching "Lawrence v. Texas" OR "539 U.S. 558" in this book
Where's the rest of this book?
Results 1-3 of 22
What people are saying - Write a review
The sodomy cases: Bowers v. Hardwick and Lawrence v. Texas
User Review - Not Available - Book VerdictLaw professor Richards (NYU) is a respected author of academic/crossover books dealing with the law and social issues, such as gay rights and feminism. Here, he focuses on two key Supreme Court cases ... Read full review
Other editions - View all
The Sodomy Cases: Bowers V. Hardwick and Lawrence V. Texas David A. J. Richards No preview available - 2009 |
Common terms and phrases
abortion abridgment adult adultery Americans Anthony Kennedy appeal argued basic human rights basic right basis Blackmun Casey Chief Justice claims Clause compelling consensual constitutional privacy constitutional right constitutionally contraception criminal cultural decision decriminalization discrimination dissent Due Process enforced equal protection feminism feminist Fourteenth Amendment free speech gay rights gay/lesbian sex acts gays and lesbians gender Georgia Griswold grounds Hardwick Harlan heterosexual homophobia homosexual human rights interpretation issue judicial Justice Kennedy Justice Scalia Justice White justify Lawrence legitimacy legitimate lesbians lives ment moral movement nonprocreational sex normative oral argument originalist overruling Bowers persons petitioners Powell Powell's prostitution question racism reasonably relationships religious right to intimate right to privacy rights-based role Romer same-sex marriage second-wave second-wave feminism sexism sexual sodomy laws sodomy statute stereotypes Texas statute tion tional tradition U.S. constitutional law U.S. Supreme Court unconstitutional United University Press voices Wade women York
Bibliographic information
| Title | The sodomy cases: Bowers v. Hardwick and Lawrence v. Texas Landmark law cases & American society |
| Author | David A. J. Richards |
| Publisher | University Press of Kansas, 2009 |
| ISBN | 0700616365, 9780700616367 |
| Length | 214 pages |
| Subjects | › › Law / Constitutional Law / General Law / Legal History Law / Privacy Political Science / Government / Judicial Branch Psychology / Human Sexuality Social Science / Gay Studies |
| Export Citation | BiBTeX EndNote RefMan |